The Archive · 1900

Prisoners of War

2nd May.

Tne history of the treatment of prisoners of war is the history of civilisation in miniature. There is more than presumptive evidence that prehistoric man killed and ate his prisoners: at the dawn of history the captives of war were used as sacrifices to the gods, men were butchered in cold blood to pro-vitiate this demon or that ghost, and to bring good luck to new social or political departures, Later on it was discovered as food increased that prisoners had a market value, and slavery became their lot; the vanquished soldier however. brave, his wife and bairns however noble, became chattels, losing by the issue of one battle, liberty, country, property, everything but their own soul and frequently even that. The Romans after a triumph flogged and then enslaved their noblest captives: their servile populations like that of Sparta exceeded that of the citizens. In medieval Europe slavery was succeeded by the ransom of the rich combatant and by the starvation and beggary of the poor, unless, as was usually the case, he turned bandit. Tater on exchange became common, though it was not unknown in antique warfare. For a thousand years in Europe, war prisoners of low degree were regarded as an undesirable accompaniment to victory: their presence was obviated by the rule of "no quarter;" ghoulish camp-followers with the poniard finished the work of the sword and the pike. It was only when Hugo Grotius published his immortal De jure belli et bacis that positive rules for the care and treatment of prisoners were made: these rules found general acceptance in Christendom though they wanted and still want the sanction of law. Since that date the betterment of the condition of pri oners, and indeed the general amelloration of war have been progressive.

Obviously the sole aim in retaining prisoners of war is to prevent them taking further part in the struggle; the ancients thought this was most feasibly done by killing them; in our times we prefer restraint, and both Municipal and International Law regard as strictly justifiable what-" ever degree of severity may be necessary to make this restraint compatible with the safety of the captors. Many prisoners in a small community, or with few guards, are subjected to far more rigid treats ment than if the conditions be reversed. If food ran short and parole were offered and refused, the prisoners might even starve without legal reprobation. The presence of 5,000 Boers at Cape Town was proving irksome to the British authorities, consequently the exile of the prisoners to St. Helena, although a new departure in their disposal in bulk, is warranted. Prisoners may refuse to help their captors in fortification and similar work and may not be punished for such refusal, There is a fine legal obscurity in the rule that "prisoners may be employed in a manner suitable to their condition." It probably implies that officers may not set to menial tasks or hard labour, and it may cover the Pauline dictum that if a man (not being sick or feeble) does not work neither shall he eat. Their earnings are their own, subject to a deduction for maintenance: failing such earnings, captors must maintain them and that also "in a manner suitable to their condition," that is to say the field-marshal fares better than the corporal.

Prisoners cannot be compelled to give information, nor are they to be punished for silence: nay further, international Law even reprobates penalties for false information, Indefinite severity is allowed the guards to maintain discipline and to prevent escape: in the case of arising, prisoners may be shot at sight: the jurists all recognise the captors' safety as the supreme consideration, Unnecessary cruelty is criminal; in 1865 a Federal court-martial hanged a Confederate officer after the war for gratuitous cruelty to his prisoners. This was a subject for fierce recrimination between French and British in the Napoleonic war: the Emperor refused big exchanges because he thought we were nearer vxhaustion than he was. The result was that the hulks were crammed till they because floating pest-houses and almost 4s hellish as those of criminals. Buildings like the Perth penitentiary were run up to meet the difficulty but they soon were as terrible as the hulks. This subject is one of the historical grievances France has against Perfidious Albion: it has, of course, an obverse side.

Exchange is' obviously the best solvent of the prisoners-of-war question, but it is only practicable where numbers, resources, and losses are fairly equal. The present war will see little of it except in the case of the permanently disabled. It is managed much as schoolboys swap apples: one for one, or a big, good one fed without permission.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account