The Archive · 1902

The United States

(FROM OUR OWN CORRESPONDENT.) — Boston, Mass., 12th May

The "Water Cure."

The American army in the Philippines finds itself in the unpleasant positron of receiving an attack in the rear and that from its own countrymen. Certain of the younger Democratic senators have seized pon stories of cruelty inflicted upon Filipinos by Ame: oldiers, have held them up for public view, pointed out and om-phasised the worst incidents, and then proceeded to credit the whole army" and. its administration with similar practices. The so-called "water cure," its use and abuse, its methods of infliction, its purpose, its permissibility under existing circumstances, its dangers, its moral effect upon the natives, is the topic of the hour in senatorial investigation and debate. The Democrats who are striving to make this an issue, reinforced by idealists in warfare,' maintain that the "American army' has gone beyond the limits set for civilised warfare. The Republicans as a whole, while admitting that there have been in= stances of unwarranted severity or cruelty, claim that conditions, on "the whole, justify the methods pursued. President Roosevelt has spoiled the force of the opposition by insisting upon immediate and searching investigation of all charges of cruelty and the prompt trial by court-martial of officers alleged " to be responsible.

Under these circumstances, what of political benefit the Democrats may reasonably hope or expect is berond comprehension. It is plain that the American

field and, however the attacks ara disguise people will stand by their army in the ed, the popular conclusion will remain that the criticisms are of the army and thus of the country's flag.

Republicans v. Democrats.

The Republicans in the Senate are vastly stronger and more resourceful than their opponents. It is almost as if the leading rs of Boston and New York were pitted in a case against the country squires of a few villages. The great business states of the country are to-day represented in the Senate by Republicans become the attorneys of the Republican and hence the great lawyers on that floor cause. Then, in numbers, the Democrats are at a disadvantage almost as great. There are thirty-three opposition Senators and fifty-five Republicans, It is an uneven match. With the great newspapers of the country the disparity is still more marked. It is a fair estimate that ninety per cent. of the voters of the dominant North read the nows of Philippine affairs in newspapers whose policy it is to present the administration cause favourably. The further West one goes the more marked becomes this predominance. Then the great business interests of the country are so well pleased with the prevailing prosperity that they dread anything which threatens to disturb it, and so look with disfavour upon the Philippine agitation in the Senate. It thus appears that about all the influences which really count in America are with the present policy.

Opposition newspapers have suggested that there might be a sufficient popular reaction against the Philippine policy to occasion a loss to the Republicans of the House of Representatives this fall. Such a result would do the Democrats no good and the Republicans little harm, and a3 for affecting the Philippine policy, there is small chance of its having any bearing Sshaterer. A Democratig House would

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account