Mr. A. P. Stokes appeared for the plaintiffs, and Mr. J.C. Hanson for the defend~ ants.
The petition reads as follows The petition of Robert Sutelife Ivy George Augustus Matthews and Edmund Bellinger Skottowe the abore-named plain-tifts shows as follows 1,—The plaintiff Robert Sutcliffe Ivy is and has been for the jast year and niore the tenant and occupant' of 7 The Bund Shanghai and is a Brit ject The plaintiff George Augustus Matthews resides at No. 1a, Kiukiang Road Shang hai and is also'a British subject and the plaintiff Edmund Bellinger Skottowe resides at No. 18 The Bund and is also a British subject.
2.—The defendants are the Proprietors of the "North-China Daily News" " newspaper which is issued daily in Shanghai, and which is printed on the premises known as No.. The Bund or ina godown adjacent thereto.
—The defendants by working their printing presses on the raid promises make jond and unbearable noises which cause an intolerable nuisance to the plaintifis and materially interfere with their enjoyment of their premises above-mentioned which are adjacent to the premises where the defendants make these loud and unbearable noises.
4.—The plaintiffs have complained of such noises, but they nevertheless persist in making them.
The plaintifis therefore pray as follows 1.—That the defendants their servants and workman and agents may be perpetually restrained from making or causing to be made noises in their business so as to occasion nuisance, disturbance and annoyance t the plaintiffs as occupants of the above-named premises respectively.
2.—That the plaintiffs may have such further or other relief as the nature of the case may require.
The defendants to this petition are Messrs. Pickwoad & Ca.
Afiidavits by the plaintiffs were handed to his Lordship, who said that he had read them.
Tu the cowse of his remarks, Mr. Stokes cited two or three eases in which the owners of factories and workshops had beau ordered to abate noises made by their machinery to the discomfort of people living in neighbouring houses. The defendants, in this case, had estab ished their printing press right in the midst of houses which were devoted to quiet methods of business, and used for residential purposes, He submitted that he was entitled to ask for an order to restrain it, and also, if necessary, that steps showed be taken to enforce Such an order.
Mr. Hanson asked that the motion should be adjourned. He had not lad time to prepare any defence, as he was ved with a notice late saturday His Lordship interposed and said that representations had been made to the defendants by the plsiniffs.
Continuing, Mr. Hanson said that both Mr. HI. Morriss and Mr. R. Litve were away, and although complaints had been made to them there was no letter sent to them threatening proceedings. A letter was written a few days ago, ant steps were now being taken to. remedy the nuisance. Windows were being closed, and the printing machines were to be placed on felt, which would deaden the noise, Other measures too had been instituted to remove cause for annoyance. It would be remembered that the " North-Chins Daily News" occupied premises a very few yards of their present establishment for several years without any complaint being made. It was a matter of common knowledge to the plaintifis that of e going to put up their ad printing works on the present site.
Some of them were the tenants of the owners of the " North-China Daily News," and they took these places knowing what they had to expect. In view of the fact that efforts wore being made to stop the noises complained of, he would ask that an adjourn me: t should be granted.
Some discussion ensued between his Lordship an-l Mr. Stokes, counsel pressing for an immediate order to the defendants to abate the nuisance.
Eventually his Lordship said that he could not pre-judge the ease. If he did so and issued an order restraining the defendants and ordering them to at once abate the nuisance very serious and irre trievable loss might, be occasioned them. Be would adjourn the case until Friday, so that a defence might be prepared.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.