The Archive · 1902

Kaw Reports

H. B. M.'s SUPREME COURT — Tientsin, 19th-21st October — Before F.S. A. Bourse, Esq. — Acting Ch'ef Justice

Texce asp Scunorrer ¢. Tae Tax Tvo'aNp Licnrer, Conraxy, Ly.

In this case the plaintiffs, represented by Mr. E. P. Allen, sought to make the defendant Company liable to the extent of Tls. 1,832 for short delivery of cargo carried in the Company's Lighters from the Indo-China Steamship Company's steamer Wosang to Tangku. Mr. Moun-sey (Messrs. Mounsey and Bruton) appeared for the Lighter Company.

The plaintifis are German subjects doing a mercantile business in Tientsin and the defendant a corporation orga ed and existing under the Compa Ordinances of Hongkong, with its prin: pal place of business at Tientsin.

In the plaintiffs' petition it was claimed that in the month of November, 1901, the Yndo-China Steam Navigation Company, Ld. delivered from its steamer Wosang, for and on behalf of the plaintiffs into the lighters, then commanded and manned!by the' servants. of defendant, certain goods, without written agreement but under an implied contract, to make full and safe delivery to the plaintiffs at Tangku; that defendant failed in making such delivery to the plaintiffs in the sum of Tls. 1,832.

The defendants, in their reply, denied any knowledge of the delivery as set out in the plaintiffs' petition, and declared that in the month of November the lighters in question were chartered by Messrs. Mondon and Ca. of Shanghai and Tientsin and were commanded and manned by the defendant company for the purpose of navigation only. They also denied any implied contract with plaintiffs or anyone else to make delivery of the goods at Tangku; and as a further answer denied all knowledge of the plaintiffs in the subject matter of the action.

The petition and answer having been read, the issues which were not very clear on the pleadings were agreed as follows Ist issue—Were these goods received on board the lighters.

2nd issue.—Were the lighters, lighters ordinarily employed in the business of the defendant Company. 8rd issue.—Ought a contract to be implied in law by the defendant Company to carry these goods for the 4th issue—Was there a special contract between the defendant Company and Mondon and Company which relieved the defendant Company of their ordinary liabilities as carriers.

Evidence in support of the first two isoness was produced by the plaintiffs and in cross examination facts were elicited supporting the defendant Company's contention that Mondon and Company had chartered the lighters. The issue, therefore, subject to the construction to be

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account