Sir, Henry Campbell-Bannerman has' publicly. welcomed the message of peace "flung" to him by Lord,, Rosebery.. He, could hardly do otherwise. "The noble Earl had declared that in face of the danger with which, in the view of Free Traders, the country and the Empire are threatened la Mr. Chamberlain's proposal, it was the duty of all Liberals to ignore the personal equation " and fight shoulder to shoulder. In the face of that declaration Sir Henry could not, even if he had been so disposed, refuse to be reconciled. So there is now but one tabernacle, and Lord Rosebery leaves his lonely furrow and takes his place once more among the Liberal leaders. But whether "C.B." altogether relished the tremendous cheering which greeted Lord Rosebery's name when he referred to the message of peace may be doubted, and the public will not be quite convinced of the reality of the recondiliation until the two men appear on one platform. Then the question arises, who will-be the leader? A strong effort' will, I believe, be made to get Earl Spencer to accept the position. Lord Rosebery could not decline to servo under Lord Spencer without laying himself open to the charge of reviving the "personal equi ation;" and as Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman has never been anything more than leader of the Liberal Party in the House of Commons, he could without loss of dignity retain this position while acknowledging Lord Spencer as a leader of the whole party. This solution of the problem is rendered all the more likely by the disclosure made in Morley's "Life of Gladstone" that when the Grand Old Man finally retired it was Lord Spencer whom he nominated for the succession to the Premiership. Whether the selection of Lerd Rosebery was due to the personal preference of the Sovereign, to intrigues in the Cabinet, or to other causes we do not know for certain, but we do know that if Mr. Gladstone had had his way Lord Spencer would have succeeded him, and then probably the dissensions which' have since played such havoc with the Liberal Party would have been avoided.
An Anti-Vivisector's Libel.
The Hon. Stephen Coleridge has been condemned to pay £2,000 damages, and costs amounting to no one knows how much for " libel against Dr. W. M. Bayliss, Assistant Professor of Physiology at University College. The case created extraordinary amount of interest. The Qourt was absolutely besieged on each of the four days of the hearing, and all the efforts of the judge could not prevent public displays of feeling both for and against the defendant. Che libel was contained in a book circulated by the Anti-Vivisection Society, of which Mr. Coleridge is honorary secretary; and it accused Dr. Bayliss of having vivisected a dog without having properly ancesthetised it according tv law. Mr. Coleridge seems to have accepted in a very reckless way the impressions of two Swedish laties—strong Anti-Vivisectionists—who witnessed the operation; and as the libel was certainly calculated to do Dr. Bayliss great harm, and its falsity was overwhelmingly proved, Mix. Coleridge cannot complain of the heaviness of the damages. It is not probable that they will all fall upon. himself: "The Anti-Vivisectionist Society numbers among its members a good many wealthy men; and they may be expectd to come to the assistance of their honorary secretary, who has erred through excess of zeal. Indeed there are many. who consider that although Dr. Bayliss did not break the law, and the dog Jon which he operated was rendered incaplable of feeling pain, there is still no i justification for the operation which he performed. Only a few extremists would forbid all experiments on living animals, but there are many who feel that vivisection should be rigidly confined to purposes of, real scientific. research. In Dr. Bayliss's cas¢ the operation was not made for research but in order to demonstrate to the stude ntscerta in well-established facts; and the argument that. the¥e facts could nathe adequately taught without vivisection was by no means conclusive. On the continent, where the restrictions vivisection are far less rigid than in Coy land, appalling suffering soft en inflicted on dumb animals in the name of science;-and I do not think anyone who has had an opportunity of judging will deny that these experiments have a tendency to render students callous to suffering. It is quite Esa to pay dearly for is indiscretion, possible that though Mr. Coleridge has
the case may lead toa further restriction of vivisection, which surely should only be permitted when there is a practical certainty that the desired end may be attained by its means and by no other means.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.