The Archive · 1904

The Yangkingpang Again

2hth November.

We have written so much about the Yangkingpang in the last three or more years, urging that it should Feulverted, the expedient supported by the Municipal Engineer, Mr. Mayne, himself some seven years ago, that we would not take up the subj ct again but that a paragraph that appeared in the Municipal minutes published last week makes some notice peremptory. The paragraph to which we refer is the following: "A letter from the French Council is read expressing the willingness of that Body to entertain atid prop sals which the Council may think fit to submit for measures to be undertaken for the improvement of this waterway, the opinion being, however, expressed that the culverting of the creek offers the only satisfactory solution. A report by the Municipal Engineer states that of er consultation with the Engineer of the French Counci!, he has agreed with the latter that the best al'ernative course to adopt lies in the ercetiao of a system of sluice gates at suitable points on the Defence Creek and the Yangkingpang. Under these circumstances it is decided to address the French Council and to request that the proposed scheme be adopted, and that the French Engineer be directed to proceed with the same in ce-operation and consultation with Mr, Mayne."

Tt is a certainty that the Yung-king-pang will be culverted sooner or later. Phe French Council holds to the opinion which it has always held, and which was at one time held by Mr. Mayne, that culverting is the only satisfactory solution. Every year our roads running east and west become more congested and the value of the wide boulevard that will be formed when the Yangking-pang is culverted becom: more and more evident'; and if there ¢uld be any d ubt as to the future value of that boulevard, it would be proved by the strenuous oppo ition that is made to the culverting by the owners of property on the older streets, The culverting has been voted once by the ratepayers on this side ofan annual meeting of ratepayers, and the question would have been submitted to them again at the last annual meeting but for Mr. McBain's untimely removal. In gaily proposing the ercc'ion of sluice gates, it does not seem to have occurred to the Council to ask the consent of the harbour authorities, and it is -evident'y forgotten that the late harbour-master, Captain Bisbee, aman whose opinion could not be disregarded, was strongly oppasel to the scheme, one rewu't of which would be, he believed, the formation of a bar in the river which would be a serious inconvenience to navigation. Under the cirenmstances the sluice-gate plain seems to us to be a serious waste of money, an expenditure which will do no lasting good, which is merely an ephemeral experiment which has never been submitted to the ratepayers; but which will have the effect, ao ardently desired by some of our landowners, of preventing the construction of the much-neded wide street between the French and the so-called British Settlements.

But the most curious thing about the decision taken by our Council and recorded in the minute quoted above is that, as far as we can ascertain, the French Cuuncil and their Engineer, M. Chollot, have no idea whatever of agreeing to, or co-operate ing in, the sluice-ga e project, even if the harbour authorities were to consent to it; and if our Council were under the impr sion, before they published the last minutes, that their proposition would meet with ready acquiescence, there must have been a very serious mis understanding somewhere, The French Council and its engineer remain of the fixed opinion, which is held by a majority of ratepayers also on this side, that the only remedy for the Yangk'ngpang is to culvert it, and we have shown in detail before that the objection founded on the cost of this—f which the French Council, altho sh the French Settlement is s> much smaller and less wealthy than ours, is willing t" pay half—is only a bugbear. They know that dredging, and sluice-gating, and other alte: nativs whatever they may be, are only expensive palliatives, which will only postpone, not obviate, the necessity fur culverting. The objection to the sluice-gate scheme is the same as that to dredging, namely, the weakness of the bunding a'ong the Yangkingpang. Isis quite true that seven years ago M. Chollot, the French Engineer, suggested that it would be better to put sluice-gates in this waterway than to do nothing at all but in seven years there has been a considerable farther deterioration in the bunding, and it is certain that it would now neither stand the dredge ing of the creek nor the rush of water that would follow the opening of the sluice-gates; and the caving-in of the bunding that would certuinly follow the adoption of either of these alternatives, would cause an enormous amount of unnecessary expense an inconvenience.

Phere are really only two alternatives; to leave the Yangkingpang alone or to culvert it. To leave it alone is to retain in the middle of the Settlements an open tidal sewer whose emanations when the tide is down are a constant danger to the public health as well as a standing offence to all who live near it or have to use the roads that border it, It only remains to culvert it; the nominal objections to this we have answered in full in the past; the real objection is such an unworthy one bel it should not he admitted for a moment,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account