The Archive · 1902

Bist May, 1902

CURRENCY IN THE PHILIPPINES

To the Editor of the "Nonta-Coma Darcy News."

Sm,—The Journal of the American Asiatic Association for April contains an account of a statement made at New York by Mr. A. M. Townsend and submitted to a Sub-Committee of the Committee on the Philippines on 13th February, 1902, It relates, of course, to the question of what currency or money should be established in the Philippines by the United States.

In advocating a straight, sound, full-weight silver dollar," by' which' Mr, Townsend means an American dollar of the same weight and fineness as the Moxican dollar and the British silver dollar, he makes several observations which are open to argument.

Speaking fof the American gold dollar, he regards a gold dollar unsuitable to the Philippines on account of the poverty of the country, stating that "gold is expensive currency and can only be held and used as money by rich countries." This is an opin. ion not infrequently put forward by sup-orters of a silver basis. It has its origin in a certain fitness of language to the un denying idea; but is based on no. scientific principle, and when examined is found, like the metal it_supports, baseless. country like the United States could keep a gold reserve inthe Philippines without finding it a "tax or burden," and all that is required for a poor country is a smaller stock of the gold reserve. It is misleading to say this will not remedy the question of an exchange rate between the nilippines and America, With a maximum range of only 1} per cent most merchants woul think the remedy complete exposed as they have recently been to fluctuations ranging up to 20 per cent.

The arsumeuts advanced against the Senate Bill No. 2295 are surely somewhat strained. If the native to whom $10 in silver is due, knew he could change at any time $5 in gold for it, he would require no persuasion to accept the gold. An amusing instance to the contrary occurred to the writer on his voyage from Singapore to Hongkong recently. He owed the ship's barber, a Cingalese, Is. Gd., but having no English silver tendered him a_ straight British silver dollar, which was reluctantly accepted; while the barman t" whom a similar sum was due took the dollar with the remark that they were accepting dollars at 1s. 6d. that voyage.

The arguments Mr. Townsend uses in favour of the silver dollar are mainly ex parte; but when he states that fluctuations on the "broad basis of silver values the world round are now very easily dealt with in all mercantile matters," and that when "buying or selling merchandise in a silver country" an exchange settlement with his bankers eliminate "all risk of fluctuations in value of a silver currency," he touches only the fringe of the ts incurred by the merchant. When buying Manchester goods in England the merchant is confronted with the task of fixing in advance of shipment, for which he usually has to pay on a sliding scale of so much per month; so that at the forward rate, fixed by the Bank, the purchase is either abandoned as leading to Joss, or the Bank levies " heavy toll the merchant takes the risk himself.

Tt. is, of course, a matter of opinion whether the transfer of the Indian currency to a gold basis has or has not been beneficial to the Empire. Fow, outside the Banking world, have any doubt that it has been of the utmost benefit; and lately one merchant expressed himself that the advantage to his business in dealing with steady exchange was incaleu!

That China merchants may some day reach the same haven of security is earnestly to be desi ud it is to be hoped also that the United States Government will pause before ib perpetuates on the trade of the Philippines, the terrible vicissitudes to which the China trade has been exposed by its retention of silver as its monetary standard.

Tam, ete.,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account