The Archive · 1903

The Cost of the Army

The principle of the establishment of army corps was generally condemned, the War Department was also called severely to account for its treatment of the volunteers, and many questions of detail were, of course, discussed; but Mr. Balfour was not far wrong when ho said that all these questions were of quite minor importance. Since the army corps are declared to exist only on paper, it is easy on paper to con: vert them into something else. The real question at issue is whether we are spending too much on our army, and, in spite of the lesson of the war, the general inion is thab we are. As Mr. Winston Churchill pointed out, the cost of the army in 1897 was £18,000,000; this year it is nearly £12,000,000 more, That is an enormous increase for so hart a period; and the general opinion is that if we must spend 60 much on national defence it would be far more effective to spend more on the navy less on the army.

Alien Inmigration.

After army reform the most interesting subject of debate in the Commons has been alien immigration. It was raised by Colonel Sir Howard Vincent in the form of an amendment to the address. He was, however, taken to task by Mr. Gerald Balfour for having introduced the subject. while a Royal Commission is sitting upon it, and all the satisfaction he got was a promise that the question should not be shelved when the Commission has done its work. Mr. Gerald Balfour at the same i argod on the difficulties of the problem, and frankly expressed his opinion that if the measure introduced by Lord Salisbury in 1894 to deal with the question had been_ passed, it would have been a dead letter. Unfortunately, two really distinct questions have been confounded in this movement. There is the question of the so-called "destitute" aliens, and there is that of the criminal aliens. With regard to the "destitute" aliens the evil has been enormously exaggerated. No doubt they compete with British workmen, but there is not so much unfairness in the competition as has been contended. The aliens who are now coming over in thousands are mostly Jews. They as a rule sober and industrious; and while Englishmen claim the right to go all over the world to carry on trade and manufacture and commerce it is hardly consistes to propose to prevent foreigners from tore. The question of criminal aliens is on quite another footway. Ikere is no doubt that habitual criminals who have made their own countries too hat to he'd them or who are attracted by the wealth of this country come here by dreds—often in organised bands; and it ought not to be beyond the power of legis ion to cheek this evil in some measure at least.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account