June 25.
Ir-has become necessary to refer publicly to one aspect of the' recent outbreak of soldiers at Ichang although we do so with great reluctance, inasmuch as if involves the prestige of both the British Navy and the British Consular Service. But the affair has occasioned much talk at Hankow and beyond, and not a little indignation; it has been discussed, we believe, by the Hankow Chamber of Commerce, and is to be made, if it has not been al-; ready, a subject of representation to the Minister in Peking and to the Admiralty, if not by the Hankow Chamber then in a. bard-' ly less emphatic way. We may, perhaps, say that we have inquired as closely as possible into the case. It is one on which comment is extremely difficult, but a recital of the essential facts on both sides is unquestionably necessary in the interests of all concerned When the looting broke out late on the night of June 4 H.M.S. Gnat, under, the command of Lieut.-Commander Hastings, was lying off Ichang. Commander Hastings immediately put his ship in a posture of defence and in readiness to receive) the foreign population should it! be necessary to take them on board; and, after consultation, with Mr. J. L. Smith, the British' Consul, he landed a party of thirteen petty officers and blue-! jackets (himself and the sublieutenant bringing the total to fifteen) and put them on guard at the Customs compound, which, we understand, was the recognized rallying point for foreigners in case of trouble. There the bluejackets remained throughout the night. They did not go out to bring in women and children, that work being done by Mr. Smith himself, Captain Hannjgan of the str. Anlan and other civilians. At one moment the question seems to have been raised whether bluejackets should be sent out, but the decision was against sending out small parties of armed foreigners. The work of bringing in the women and children was not completely accomplished. Some twenty women, we are informed, were never brought to the Customs compound at all. One was robbed and maltreated by looters at no great distance from the compound; one, we are told, hid in a ditch all night; all must have endured the greatest terror amid the firing and burning that was going on all about them. Why, it is asked, could not civilians have been put to guard the compound, which they could well have done, and the bluejackets have been sent out systematically to round up and bring in women and children, which work, the gunboats being on the river for the protection of British subjects would seem to be their first duty' It is further contended that the prestige of the British Navy has, suffered in consequence.
The other side of the story is this. It is impressed on all British naval officers serving in these waters that they are not to intervene to prevent British property from being looted or destroy: ed: that is the duty of the Chi ese Government. As regards tie protection of British lives, the circumstances of the case must decide the line of conduct to be followed, but it has to be remembered that the naval officer cannot take action on his own account without instructions from the consul, who, from his more intimate acquaintance _—with Chinese affairs, is presumed ta be! able to form a better judgement of what is required. In respect of Ichang the Gnat's available landing party was very small, only fifteen, officers included, and the whole weight of military opinion is that it would have been the worst possible tactics to split these men, up in smaller parties and send them out on strange ground, where they might easily be ambushed and the whole force destroyed. In passing, it may be mentioned that exactly the same difficulty occurs in using the much more numerous S.V.C. in times of public disturbance. At Ichang there was a further circumstance to weigh against sending out the bluejackets. It appears to have been the Consul's opinion, which is supported by others, that the intention of the looters was in no sense antiforeign. On one occasion he called out to some looters warning them not to touch foreign property and they replied '"That's all right, we're not hurting foreigners."" It is even contended that where foreigners were molested, it was because of some personal antagonism to them, not! that they were foreigners. We cannot, of course, vouch for this, and when hundreds of men are out looting, no one can tell what may happen. But in all circumstances, the Consul may have felt that it would be safer to entrust the rescue work to civilians, well known by sight in Ichang, than to send out armed and uniformed men, unable to speak Chinese and whose mere appearance would excite suspicion and animosity.
As we have said, it is impossible for the outsider to express an opinion one way or the other. Yet the ugly fact remains that number of women remained all night in a state of great terror if not actual peril, and it has been, observed with bitterness that as soon as the American and Japanese gunboats arrived (next day, we think) they made no bones about landing men and making, a display of force. Speaking quite generally we urged, when the news first came down, that gunboats must be allowed greater freedom of action in keeping order, which the Tuchuns are powerless to keep. But such a course obviously, necessitates increasing the number of gunboats.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.