The Archive · 1904

THE BELGE-AMERICAN RAILROAD "ENTERPRISE

From rae\"New York Jouxna or Commence."

The statement has gone around the newspapers of the country that the recognition by the Department of State of the Canton-Hankow Railway as an American enterprise is calculated to increase American influence in China and is a notice of "hands off" to Russia, Tt happens that nothing could be much farther from the truth. There can be no question that, as originally organised and planned, this enterprise was accepted as evidence that American energy and capital would be freely employed in equipping China with the appliances of modern civilisation. The concession was given to Americans on the special ground that it was highly desirable, for the future of China, to enlist in the work of deve-Jopiog the material resources of the empire the aid of a nation which not only bad no designs of ita owa ea the territory of China, but which was vitally interested in counteracting the designs of other nations on that territory. Both by the re-Btates this point was strongly insisted on presentatives of China and the United

when the contract was signed with the Brice syndicate in 1898 for the construction of the Canton-Hankow Railroad, and that, contract expressly guards the nationality of the enterprise against alienate hen General Parsons and his surveying party went over the route to be traversed by the proposed American railroad, the advent of Citizens of the United States in the field of Chinese railroad constructions was everywhere the subject of congratulation, Mr. Charles Denby, Jr., who uccumpanied the party as interpreter, said in a me article published in 1899, that he would never forget the enthusiasm with which the people and the officials along the line welcomed American ce-operation in Chi-nose railway construction. In the concluding paragraph of his very intere: book An American Engineer in Chin General Parsons says that in the work of regeneration in China the influence of the United States "should be, and for many reasons inevitably will be, a pre-Pouderating weight." Thus, he added, following the rule that the world's progress has always been from the rising to the setting sun, "after a lapse of five thousand years, the youngest of the great nations is preparing to pass on, or rather to return, this light to the oldest, whence it started on its circum-orbem' journey."

As has already been explained at sufficient length in these columns, the control of the American China Development Company hes passed into the hands of a syndicate at the head of which is the King of the Belgians, and the conduct of the first and only work which it has undertaken—the construction of the Canton-Hankow Railway—is supervised not from New York, but from Brussels, the members of the nominally American organisation here being merely agents of those higher in authority on the other side of the Allantic. It does not greatly matter in whose names the stock may stand on the books of the corporation if its real ownership be elsewhere. In these circumstances it is difficult to see how American influence in China is to be promoted, or Chinese apprehensions as fo the extension of Russian influence through railroad ownership are to be allayed, by any declaration on the part of our Government that it still regards the American China Development Company American corporation, and that this Government alone has the right to deal with diplomatic questions affecting the interests of the company. In point of fact, we em imagine no more fatal blow to American influence than its covert use for the promotion of ends equally foreign to the avowed policy end, aims of this Government and to the interests of our commerce in China. In the magazine article already quoted from, Mr. Denby points: out that the Chinese negotiated with Belgians for the construction of the railroad from Peking to Hankow, because Belgium was supposed to be a small country without designs on China, and hence safer to deal with than aggressive colonial Powers, such as France, for example, with whom China was in Constant trouble on her southern border. As a matter of fact, however, the ink was not dry on this contract before an official publication by the Minister of Foreign Affairs at Paris congratulated the French people on the success of French diplomacy, and made the following statement: The result secured is due to the perseverance of French and Belgian manufacturers, actively seconded by their respective governments, and the representatives in Chins of France and Belgium." Mr. Denby goes on to show how a contract for this line was first offered in 1896 to an American'syndicate, which, having gone to the length of sending a survey party over it, dropped it In the face of Belgian competition. ''he Belgians, backed by France and Russix, eagerly seize ed it; terms with them were no object. They wished to got the contract into their hands and cut off competition, feeling sue of being able eventually to modify the contract (0 suit themsolv Tt would seem that the history of the Peking-Havkow concession was about to be repeated in that of the Hankow-Canton, The latter contract, which was secured in face of the persistent opposition of the concestioialces of the Northern road, was described by Mr. Denby as ''a si business mat ing ro political background." the enterprise was simply this: "It is intended'on the part of China to establish means of communication through three rich and prosperous provinces, while it is the purpose of the Americans interested to. obtain a profitable investment and to enter an attra eld of industry." Mr. Denby was quite right in his assumption that the undertaking would be favourably regarded in Washington, and he was quite justified in the assumption that "France und Belgium will be less inclined to interfere with it since our little episode with Spain." But, unfortunately, the enterprise did not prove tempting to American capital a8 had boon ai pated, and, seizing a favourable opportunity, the Belgians accomplished by the simple process of purchasing a controlling interest in the stock of the American China Development Company an apparent right to. dispose of the Canton-Hankow concession at their pleasure.

The action of our State Department in regard to the status of the company, which has thus passed into foreign hands, derives new interest from the reported determination of the Chinese Viceroys whose provinces are to be traversed by the railroad eto refuse to recognise the validity of ith concession in ite present hends. Wuchang and Canton appear to have more accurate information on this subject than is obtainable in Washingto, and as it happens to be the Chiness authorities who must be the ultimate judge of whether the American concession+ naires have lived up to their contract, it is the verdict of the Southera Viceroys' that will carry weight in Poking rather than that of our Department of State. Happily, our Government reserved its right to cease ite recognition of and assistance to the American China Development Company in case of any change in the organisation or conduct of that corporation which may seem to justify such action, Confronted by the proofs on which the Chinese Government bases its attitude toward the concession, the Department of State is nob likely to paraist in considoringthe American China'Development Company to be in good faith an American company.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account