To the Editor of the "Norra-Cama Dairy News."
Sirn,—May I have space in which to explain what was written in Cathedral Notes, and criticised last Friday by "an English Churchman." J am not concerned merely to prove myself right and "An English Churchman" wrong: for that is the essence of controversy.
"An English Churchman" in his extremely interesting letter doubts that there is any difficulty for a Churchman "'to guess within miles of accuracy what his fellow Churchman feels himself pledged to believe." He says that "if such a state of things really exists it is inexcusable and must be traced to some extraordinary defect of knowledge or of conscience."
I entirely agree; but there is some difficulty even for the instructed in marking the limitations of the extremes of an Anglican's belief.
First I would mention briefly the variety of practice in the domain of the English Church. A man's actions reflect his beliefs, or they should do. For example, nonchalance in Church is the reflexion of that same ingredient in the spirit. His belief is marred by an inadequate conception of God and it is a sure sign of his mental and religious attitude to the Sacraments and the presence of God. Precision, care, and accuracy in externals denote taste, character and disposition in the person.
For example, if a guest, knowing better, appears at dinner in ordinary dress, brown boots and white socks just because he prefers it, his presence is valued accordingly. It does matter how you do things.
In the matter of variety of beliefs, I hold that there are wide limits of interpretation; and after all, the substance of belief is the interpretation of real truth or dogma. The Eastern and the Western Church both inherited the Truth, but each has interpreted it differently and there is therefore at least one important diverge ence between them.
Now for some of the differences amongst Anglicans X believes in the verbal inspiration of the Bible and__ presumably regards Job and Jonah, Huppim, Muypim, and Ard and their circumstances in much the same way as he looks out upon Christ and the Gospels, or St. Paul and the Epistles. Y_ believes that God inspired those who, wrote the Bible and allows that the Bible as we have it after its chequered career of mutilation, suppression, exile and so forth, may have mistakes which are discovered and proved by Biblical scholarship. There is a world of difference between these two positions.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.