1. The affairs of ing and Parker are so involved and complex, their interests in their various ventures overlapping and inter lapping that it is almost impossible to arrive abt the true position of these two men to each other and makes it most difficult to form opinion with amy feeling of absolute certainty. Parker we have had before us. He was not a witness who volunteered much information, in fact he was somewhat reticent and indeed at time caused even his own counsel to approach irritability when endeavouring to get an answer to questions which were being put to him. The other party to the contract, King, is dead.
2. I hesitate to place too great reliance on the overheard conversations. Conversations are always dangerous evidence to rely upon because we get the hearers' impression of what was—meant which may be an entirely different impression from that which the we speakers were conveying to each other.
Taking into consideration that from August, 1906, when this company cancelled the agreement up to the time of his death in 1915, King received no payment under the agreement nor made any effort to enforce it and also taki into consideration the facts connected with his association with the China Land Company, I have come to the conclusion thay the balance of evidence is in favour of the defendants wud therefore find that on the facts before me the agreement of March 10, 1903 was can-jeelled by mutual consent in 1908, and consequently the plaintiff has iailed to support her claim, Tue Srarvte o& Liararions.
I consider that it is advisable that I should also give a decision. on the question of the Statuta of Limitation in the event of this case being taken to a higher Court.
I listened with much interest to Mr. Macdonald's able and-learned argument on the point that the present action is not an action which comes within the Statute of Limitations Act, 1623 (21 fae Lo. 16 3) in which he followed the development of. the various actions recited in sec. 3 of that Act "1623 "All actions of account, ete.' must be commenced and sued upon within six years.
It is urged on behalf of the plaintiff that this is net an action account.
cannot acespt that argument.
The statement of claim asks for "an account of the said premium become from March 10. 1905, te 1915 and payment of the amount found due.''
This claim docs not in any material manner differ_from that in Keox v. Gye (L.R.)_ 1871-2 (English and Irish Appeals Volk. V) In that case, which passed through all the lower courts and reached the highest court of the Realm, to the House of Lords, the claim was that an account might be taken of
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.