The Archive · 1923

The Flood of Bad Paper

The story of necessity begins with the issue of copper notes by the official bank, the Hsing Yeh Yin Hang. The local market was flooded with this unsecured paper under the last Tutung, Chang Ching-hui. Every effort was made to collect all local revenues in silver and to pay all official accounts in paper. The soldiers were paid in paper and were relied upon to keep the notes up to par by forcing the merchants to accept them at face value. As everyone knows Chang Ching-hui's Fengtien following was quite capable of performing this service so the oficial harvest was an abundant one. It was so abundant indeed that silver began to be scarce. Lest any silver get away, therefore, and so that the cow might be milked dry proclamations were issued and posted by the Tutung's yamen and the police headquarters on April 21 and 28, 1921, putting a ban upon the shipment of silver outside the Chahar district. Although foreign-ens were not exempted from this ruling in the text of the proclamation, the officials understood that to apply this ruling to foreigners would be a violation of treaty rights. No attempt was therefore made to prohibit foreign merchants from carrying silver out of "the district and no Official notice of the prohibition was sent to any consulate or conveyed to any: Legation through the Waichiaopu.

This pst spring, after the Chihli-Fengtien war, General Chang Hsi-yuan, commander of the Luchum 4th Mixed Brigade, supplanted General Chang Ching-hui as Tutung. He carried out his predecessor's financial policy, whether from the same motives of gain or because the market was already 60 flooded with depreciating paper that he could not take it up. Foreigners continued to take silver to Urga and other points whenever such funds were required for their own purposes of trade and the officials continued to enforce upon Chinese the bam upon silver shipments. No attempt was ever made to hold up foreign silver except in one instance when a large shipment known to belong to the Reds in Urga passed through. This was confiscated but the Red authorities in Urga promptly recovered the same amount of money from the merchants in Urga by assessment. This served to discourage further attempts at interference. Still no notice of the existence of the embargo was conveyed to either consuls or foreign merchants.

As the Chinese officials point out, however, it would be absurd to assume that the consuls resident in Kalgan and their nationals doing business there were ignorant of the existence of this embargo or of its application to Chinese money shipments, They also take pains to point out that whether foreigners think the regulation just or unjust, it is a Chinese law to which Chinese in Chahar are amenable and that foreigners who assist Chinese in getting silver out of Chahar are aiding and abetting Chinese in a violation of the law. This is unanswerable, and it is the first clause in a plea of provocation which the Chinese are preparing to make in the Coltman case. The Chinese case in full, including some important details which do not agree with Mr. Sokobin's account, as it is given in the written statement published by Chief of Staff. Meng Hsing-kuei, and as it was outlined to the writer in interviews which he had in Kalgan with the Chief of Staff, with Commissioner of Foreign Affairs Chang Shao-tseng, and with other Chinese attached to the Tutung's headquarters.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account