A Counter-claim for Carelessness and Negligence In the U. 8. Court on Tuesday before his Honour Judge Lobingier, Mr. A. T, Steele brought forward a motion for the transfer to his Honour's Court of the case of ON.
Franklin v, Steele pending in the Commissioner's Court.
In answer to his Lordship, Mr. Steele stated that the original action against him was for Tls. 250 for lawyer's fees, and he had counterclaimed for $2,000. As the Commissioner had jurisdiction only up to the amount of G.$500, he held that the matter should be heard by his Honour. Mr. Steele added that his counterclaim was for negligence and carelessness on the part of Mr. Franklin, His Honour—If you prove your counterclaim up to $500, the Commissioner can give judgment for that amount and no more. It would then be open to you to take an independent action. But you cannot deprive him of jurisdiction by filing a claim for a higher amount than he has jurisdiction over. If that could be generally adopted, it would practically nullity the Commissioner's jurisdiction.
Mr. Steele—It would serve the cause of justice by having the whole matter tried by your Honour.
His Honour—It might. The point is, we are bound by certain definite rules and we have got to follow them.
Mr. F. J. Schuhl, appearing for Mr. Franklin, asked that the petition be dismissed, quoting several cases showing that the point had already been ruled upon against the position taken up by applicant, His Honour—If the judgment rendered ig adverse to you, you are amply covered by appeal. If it is not adverse, you have no. ground for complaint.
Mr. Steele then said he had not participated in the case.
His Honour—You should partic-pate, Mr. Steele—Your Honour will compel me not to do so if you refuse. I am determined not to participate in the trial in the Court below.
His Honour took the matter into Mr. ©. Chicken and family have Jeff Kobe for England. After his recent very serious illness, Mr. Chicken was ordered a long rest by his medical advisors, and his return to the Orient depends upon whether this re-establishes his health, In any case he may join another branch of his firm. His many friends in Kobe will regret his departure. Mr. Chicken has, while in Kobe, taken an active and generally leading part in many committees and other bodies which do public work. He was formerly resident of Shanghai.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.