The Archive · 1923

A Libel Action in U. S. Court

Possibility of Settlement by Defendant Apologizing The action for libel, arising out of a charge of adultery of which he was recently acquitted, by Perey R. Moore against Jay Elmont, of 27 Quinsan Gardens, was resumed before his Honour Judge Lobingier at the U. S. Court on Thursday. Damages for $20,000 are claimed, the alleged libel being contained in the following advertisement, inserted by defendant in the "Shanghai Gazette" while plaintiff was on trial:—"Speak about the Moore ease. If that bird did not put a More in Mormon, he certainly did not put it in Morality. All one has to do is to go down Whangpoo Road of a morning and hear the things said about it. Asbestos earmuffs need not be worn either Mr. F. J. Schuhl is appearing for plaintiff and Mr. P, F. Faison for defendant, Defendant was the only witness heard. In cross-examination by Mr. Schuhl, he was asked: What did you mean by this statement concerning Moore, Mormon and Morality?—I did not mean anything by it.

Did you ever give evidence that the hotel belonged to your wife and

did.

you were the manager?—I In reply to further questions, witness denied making an affidavit "in reference to the advertisement. The two houses in Quinsan Gardens did not belong to his wife. The furniture did. He was manager of the establishment.

Addressing his Honour for de fendant, Mr. Faison' said that no evidence had. been adduced that the advertisement was libellous. Eltant no malicious intent. There was, further, nothing to show that the advertisement was generally understood by the community to have reference to Mr. Moore's moral character. Damage might possibly have flowed from it in that iti might have held him in public gaze in ai rather unpleasant light, but the advertisement could not be said to have specifically charged Moore with immorality.

Mr. (olson proceed to state that he did not wish to go on with the defence, as he would have to bring up unpleasant details regarding the recent charge of adultery. If Elmont apologized, could the case be dismissed The Judge—The advertisement was not the kind of article that should be published while a case is pending. It constituted a very serious proposition for a man on trial whose reputation is at stake. There is no need of evidence to prove that newspapers are That the advertisement was intended for commercial purposes does not mitigate it in any way.

Mr. Faison—If an apology is not accepted, we will fight it out and Moore's reputation will be again at stake The Judge suggested that a settlement might be effected between the parties.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account