Motion for a Re-hearing of the Suit: Counsel's Argument in U.S. Court 'A motion for a new trial of the suit brought by Mr. Herbert Webb against the Me. was heard by Judge Purdy in the U. S. Court on Monday, morning. In presenting the motion Mr. W. S. Fleming stated that in is opinion one of the cases upon which the Judge had based "his decision, namely Carpenter Steel Ca.
Noreross, was not analogous to the Webb case, and he' begged to point out the differences upon which he founded his request for a new trial, In referring to the case of the Carpenter Steel Ca. against Norcross, Mr. Fleming held that the directors. of the plaintiff Company had practically condoned the action of Nor-eross in entertaining and drinking: with prospective customers in order to secure the sale of motor cars and this was customary in such Dusiness transactions, while the same could not be said of the Webb case. The drinking in the Carpenter Steel Ca, case was not done on the premises of the firm, argued Mr. Fleming, while the editor of the "China Press" instead of conducting himself with the dignity due the responsible position he held had made his office "nothing but a bar room." Even though the directors. had consented to the continuance of the canteen, Mr, Fleming said, they did not know that Webb and his as-
Sociates were shaking dice all the time, At this point Judge Purdy interposed to ask whether Mr. Fleming thought that was quite a fair statement, as he felt that the evidence did not bear it out.
Mr. Fleming maintained that the testimony stated that Mr. Webb would take three or four drinks in the afternoon and the same number night, which I should call continuous "drinking, declared Mr. Fleming.
"But you must remember," replied lat all the witnesses. agreed that Mr. Webb had a wonderful capacity." (Laughter.)
Nothing to be Gained Judge reviewed the local comparing it with the case and said finally that in his opinion nothing would be garned by new trial, as nothing in the argument had' led him to change his mind. He had considered the facts urged by Mr. Fleming; but in consideration of Mr. Webb's long employment by the "China Press" and the fact that the canteen had been in existence during that time he doubted whether drinking had materially affected Mr. Webb's ability to perform his duties. The fact that the canteen and Mr. Webb' drinking were never considered up to the very time of his discharge and were only brought forward after other measures had been taken to effect his discharge had influenced his decision. Believing that nothing would be gained by a new trial the [Judge denied the motion,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.