The Archive · 1905

to Mr. F. E. Taylor's remarks

Mr. Twentyman gave as the reason for Mr. Rawsthorne and myself leaving his firm: "that we had asked for more than his company cared to pay."

This is absolutely false so far as Mr. Rawsthorne and myself are concerned, we made no attempt to increase our sulsries, the first and only intimation S. C.F.B.& Ca. Lal, got from us was our signations, Tam, ote.

R. B, Mavemay, The Kiangnan Dock and Engineering Works, 24th June, To the Editor of the "Nontu-Cuixa Darty News."

Sin,—In your report of the annual mooting of the Dock Company, i I was unable to be present, the Chi is stated to have referred to the circular letter of the 13th April addressed to the Directors as vindictive. As one of the signatories of the letter in question I claim any other motive than legit m of the action of the Board The value of the " definite offer which was submitted to the shareholders a pended upon whether there were reason grounds for bel toon £1 shares in ti new Company would be worth par of flotation; it is obvious that the future value of these £1 shares depended irely upon an agreement as to the limitation of a farther issue of ordinary or preference 8 or of debentures, and the terms upon which such issue would be per-

It is clour that without an agreement in this sense the purchasing syndicate might have rendered the new £1 shares of little or no value. Before taking the responsibility of submitting the scheme to the shareholders the Directors ought to have safeguarded this entry point, or to have made it plain that they had not done so. They apparently took neither course; the Chairman stated that after months of negotiation it seemed to the Directors that the final offers left very little room, if any, for a return on the original shares.

It was the precipitate action of the Board in submitting a crude scheme which was adversely criticised, and not the general management of the Company, with has given 'a retura to the chars? holders for many years of which the Directors may be proud.

In the future, further questions of a non-technical character affecting the Company's welfare may arise; changes in the management are inevitable sooner or later; at present the Board of Directors have practically the power of electing their successors; under these circum. stances it is surely worthy of consideration whether it is in the best interests of the Company this arrangement should be permanent, even after the retirement of the who have made the Company or whether the basis of representation dead. on the Bosrd should not be extended.

Many case there seems to be no reason why the suggestion should be looked upon as hostile to the present Directors.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account