Continuing the cross-examination, Mr. Macleod elicited the fact that this note was the only contract to buy the Eden-dale. Witness could not find the lette:
When be sent the Tls. 2,000 to Mr, Pavlow he did not write a letter and yet at that time he had no connection with Mr. Pavlow. It was not direct from him that he was asked to send that sum, Mr. Phillips—That is my case, my Lord.
His Lordship—I may say at once for the information of Counsel shat I propose to ask the jury to find a special verdict, wud to ask you to argue after. At the present mouient you meed not argue law but only the facts. merman was 80 well-known as a Russia and he was the man referrer to in Novoye Vremya." The plaintiff and ness had a long conversation shen he went to see him about the Samson and Pavlow said that he should sue Ward. Witness asked hit it he did not think that it would be better 10 settle the rustter quietly ax taking it into Court might create a scandal, and Pavlow replied that he would ruin Baron Ward nnd Bennet Bur-h. Ultimately by Ward's instructions witness suid the "Samson back to the original owners for the sum of Tls. 57,000 with the condition that it could be repurchased in a certain time at a fixed figure if Mr. Pavlow in the meantime settled the claims that he had promise! to dv. The price that the Samson was sold for was much better than any other that had been received elsewhere. The Samson was xold the Grst instance by Messrs. Wheelock on erudition that she was not: to trade in
on sale Messrs. Wheelock were to have the the Yangize or Shanghai waters an that fir-t refusal of her. Out of the Tls. 57,000 witness retained over Tls. 50,000. Tls. 40,000 was retained "n account of the Edendale and the hospital supaiies, and bout Ils. 11,000 expenses of the Samson, and Tls. 1,000 for medical towels supplied and paid for. The medical stores and supplies were all paid for by Pavlow, through Baron Ward, with the exception of this Tls. 1,000. Witness had bad in hand Tls. 38,800 in the shape of bargain money but he did not retain it because the plaintiff insisted that he would be Mr. Wilkinson—You do not wish to hear Counsel now as to wi Pavlow was, as a fact, acti Russian Government His Lordship—I shall leave that ques. tion to the jury. {tis purely a matier of fact. I may not ask the question in that form but the question must go to the jury.
Mr. Phillips then rose to address the jury He said that the first point that he would ask the jury to devote their attention to was the capacity in which Mr, Pavlow brought this case, und he must remind the jury that Mr. Paviow was the plaintiff and claimed the sum of Tls. 101,000 f r the conversion of the Saumon, and damages. With regard to thee pacify in which tie plriutef brought this ca-e hw said him-elf Unt he brought it in his personal capwity and not in his profess anal capacity. Counsel suggested to the jury that he was nut entitled 10 bring the case in that way In these trausictions he acted as the agent for the Russia: Govern-went. The jury woul: remember the correspondence that passed between Mr Pavlow and Baron Ward with rezurd to the purchase of he Samson, and the letters that had brew read aw! put in, The one dated the 14th of October,1904, signed by Mr. Pavlow gid: We can discuss matters alerwards as there are so many details which wust be arranged in regard ty vue schsine. I have telegraphed on the subject of the ship and hope 10 have " rep y 10- morrow." On the 18th of Uctober he said "1 received yesterday another telegram containing" instructions not to spend more thaw Tls. 100,000, but I
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.