Oct, 14.
Mr. Tong Shao-yi's recent criticism of the Tariff Conference has drawn from General 'Ting Shih-yuan, vid our Peking correspondent, a very intere ing, but not convincing reply. We' do not "back" Mr. Tong, more than any other prominent Chinese but his criticism struck; us as being the soundest pronouncement, going to the root] and essentials of China's present, needs that we have seen. eral Ting Shih-yuan, whose! sincerity we would not question' for a moment, misses the real] point of the situation. It is not} a question whether China should have Customs autonomy or an. increase in her tariff, but of taking first things first, And while China remains in her present disorganized state, in which no one can say who will be sitting in Peking to-morrow, or whom or what he will represent, the tariff is an utterly secondary and unimportant m ter, and a conference about it and nothing else will do more harm than good. General Ting reproaches Mr. Tong with being]
armchair critie—to which! charge, of course, he is open' while he remains out of politics—and with not joining Marshal Tuan's Government. But if he did not believe that that Government could do any good, why should he join it? And' what] has it done? It has not brough China any nearer unity settled order of things th was before; gnd, as rej external affairs, it' supported the strike and boycott openly and actively, and still permits the! boycott of shipping and Hongkong. The record is one without, parallel in the annals of civilized Powers. Recently there has! been a good deal of hasty window- ing and pretence of conciliatoriness. But the change! is so sudden, the purpose so obvious and the whole game so exactly Like what we have seen twenty times before, that how] can we not be suspicious?
The plain fact of the situation is that political life in China is in no condition to make it possible to negotiate with her with any prospect of good_results, unless the discussion first! centres on essentials and secures reformation at the source. One of the devices of Marshal Tuan Government was to call al People's Conference in Peking to decide on a constitution and to bring the people, as distinct from Tuchuns and politicians, into direct touch with the country's affairs. It sounded good; but, what is the result? The following paragraphs, received yesterday from our Wuchang correspondent, show us. And observe, these siatemeats are not the invention of the wicked foreigner, eager to throw dirt, but are taken. from the Chinese press of the Hupeh capital:—The local papers are full of the! 'Hupeh elections scandals. After the farce of the elections of three weeks ago, it was decided that the elections must be repeated in each hsien, First of all, the date was fixed for October 1.' Then, owing to the distance of some of the counties, the date was postponed to the th, and now. it has been again postponed to the 12th. Meanwhile the elected delegates from, a good number of the counties are already in Wu-Han. They have already met together in 'a Hankow hotel, and fixed the price of a vote at tion at home, and then come to Wuchang in order to sell their vote to the highest bidder. These in their turn will go to Peking in the confident expectation of recouping themselves out of their squeeze at the People's Conference.
To crown all, it is reported in the city that the names of the delegates have been actually fixed by the Local authorities before the elections are allowed to take place. The Anfuites are to have six men, another political clique (known as the Shih Li P'ai or Realist Party) five, the Army four, the Provincial A' sembly two—and the people none at all!
A Japanese telegram to-day says that the elections have been postponed again. The question inevitably we they ever worth holding'
Can we make it clear that we in no way whatever anta-
We only urge that the scope of the discussions to begin on the 26th instant may be enlarged to include what is going to be really useful to China, We are told that that is to be done, that everybody recognizes that the two-and-a-half per cent, surtax contemplated by Washington is no use now. But whether the surtax is two or twelve or twenty, it is equally useless. If} two-and-a-half would have served in 1921, but now it must be, say, five, what.is the irresistible inference, except that four years hence it will have to be as much more? Gifts of money will no. more cure China's ills than a. child with a bilious attack is to be cured by dosing it with Buszard's cake. If China is to regain healthiness of life, her' leading men must make a' new tart. Provincial Assemblies and People's Conferences will avail nothing until the Tuchuns get together round a table, sink their' differences and combine to give China a real instrument of government. That is the sort of conference that is needed and the Powers the ability to get it called. If they, being gathered together through their plenipotentiaries now assembling, made it plain that they would not be put off by shams, that they would not accept the pretence of a united China which is even now threatening to burst into new civil war, that they would no longer put up with the fiction that Peking is the Government of China, though it ha: less real power than many a county magistrate, that conferlence would meet and China would have real cause to call it blessed.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.