February 5.
In the December number of the Journal of the American Asiatic Association" (reviewed by us recently) prominence was given to an official communication from Washington designed to show that Mr. C. R. Crane's recall was meant to correct any false impression that American policy in the Far East involved antagonism to Japan. Before the publication of the January number the choice had fallen upon Mr. William J. Calhoun to fill the vacancy at Peking and the appointment serves the "Journal" with an opportunity for one of the most incisive critiques on the State Department's attitude in respect of China that we have yet seen. In general form President Taft's policy has not changed from that which be laid down in Shanghai in October, 1907: preservation of China's territorial integrity; equality of commercial opportunity; sympathetic on-couragement along the path of reform. But in detail there is a marked loss of the lucidity that distinguished that programme. For example, it is pointed out, in his message to Congress the President alludes to the hypothecation of likin revenue to foreign bankers as a guarantee that the respective Governments of those bankers would have a certain direct interest in China's fulfilment of promised re-"forms. Yet it might have seemed superfluous to remind any student' of Chinese affairs that the total abolition of likin ranks among the first reforms to be undertaken, and that to use it as security for foreign loans must te be surest my of President att intimates that the perpetuating the system. Again,
United States Government is en-reform etc., and to secure the needfal acquiescence of the Treaty Powers; although the Department of State must have been aware "that China's new series of commercial treaties, beginning with the British Treaty of September, 1902, have virtually died in the effort to be born Tt is thus rather worse than a wassie of time to_be canoe of the other Treaty Powers ing to secure the needful acquies-
in a bargain which China is con-fossedly unable to carry out and in stipulations which everybody knows to be impracticable."
The incongruity is indeed so obvious that the question must arise whether the American Government
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.