The Archive · 1905

The Immigration Question in America

20th October.

THE agitation in China, brought about by the mal-administration of the Chinese Exclusion Act, or by the feeling that the laws referring to this question are unjust, is, perhaps, in some measure at least, responsible for the increased attention that is being given to the problem presented by the rapid increase of the alien population in the United States. And, as we know, the same question has been the subject of legislative action in Great Britain lately. The immigration statistics of the United States show that an ever-increasing number of people from almost every country of Europe are flocking to that country. The first half of the present yenr witnessed a tremendous jump in the figures, and it would, surprise no student of the subject should the annual immigration, which lush year was approximately 1,100,000, increase to a million and a half within three years or to a round two million in from five to eight years, But even this high figure Would be very much increased should a famine, a civil war, or any period of social unrest, arise among the teeming populations of Eastern Europe. Under these circumstances it is not surprising to learn, as we do by the American mail just to hand, that the attention of Congress will be urgently directed to these subjects by the reports of Secretary of Commerce and Labour Metcalf, Commissioner-General Sargent, Commissioner Robert Watchorn, and the recommendations in the presidential message.

But, while the incoming tide is rising to heights undreamed of. earlier days, it is the quality of the newer immigration as much as the, quantity that is causing much anxiety to the well. wishers of the Republic. The last annual report of Commissioner-General Sargent shows that the Slavs hold the first place in their rush for the New World, followed by the by Teutonic, the Latin, and the Celtic, settlements and their intolerable in the order named. From one-half two-thirds of the total stream is now. composed of Russians, Austro-Hungarians, Calabrian Italians, and Hebrews, It is aot surprising that such being the case, a Canadian editor is reported to have said "in conversation with a citizen of the United States, "For many years you have admitted without let or hindrance the scum of Europe to your citizenship, and you are now reaping the consequences." From an educational point of view, too, these immigrants, are verytundesirable acquisitions. Their illiteracy, at this period of history, is scarcely creditable, For instance, more than one-half of those who came from Southern Italy were unable to read or write, and those fron other parts of Europe, though not so bad as this, had, nevertheless large percentage of illiterates among them. Then, too, vast numbers. of immigrants were unskilled only one-seventh of the Italians could turn their hands to crafts of any sort, and two-thirds of them were labourers, And we are not surprised that crime, so largely the outcome of ignorance, is also very prevalent among these immigrants. A recent writer, in summing up the matter says. "In fact, practically all the aliens of Eastern Europe who are now coming to us (excepting the Hebrews, whose level of industrial efficiency is high) are recruited from a peasantry, the most backward and - unenlightened in the civilised world."

Another serious phase of the question is the unequal distribution of the multitudes who arrive. It seems] uj to be a well-established fact, and a regrettable one to boot, that where they are most needed, they least go. In the trans-Mississippi and Southern States are vast. areas demanding a larger population not only for the proper tillage of the soil, but also in grazing, mining, manufacturing, and commerce. But they will not go to these -places instead they go to choke up the large cities in the east and nearer west. It is asserted by writers on the subject, and we can well believe it, that their presence also adds greatly-to the gravity of the labour-problem, serious enough as it already is, and, perhaps, ihat is worst of all, their closely-packed urban congestion in a number of the leading cities, they form a social sore that threatens one day to fester into intolerable corruption What is to be done in the way of remedies for immigrationills? Various plans have been suggested; bub restriction along racial lines is not much in favour—it is un-American, A heavy poll tax has been proposed and is looked upon with favour in certain influential quarters. But the difficulty in this connection is thab in' many cases it would be to the advantage of the employer to pay this tax in order to make it possible to secure cheap labour from abroad. -What many consider to be a much wiser proposal is that there should be a severe educational qualification. Among the other remedies suggested are an army and navy or a police standard of physical efficiency required of every "male alien; extension of the list of bauned diseases; exclusion of physical undesirables generally; proof of wage-earning capability by practical tests and. exclusion of classes of labourers with which the American labour market is at the time over-supplied. There is als feeling that the need of home legislation is also urgent, The present haphazard system of nuturalisation needs to be altered. Under this system fraud is easy, What. is needed, it is claimed, is that "a uniform naturalization law should carefully:. prescribe the form and reading of the document, and," if possible, limit the power to' confer it a few specified courts of high authority." The alien contract luw, generally conceded to be an unfortunate piece of legislation, also needs to be attended to. And then as to what, perhaps, may be regarded as the most difficult question of all, how to get rid of the festering crowds of unassimilated aliens that ave found in the great cities, Various remedies are suggested, but the effectiveness of any one of them may be doubted. Ts is generally conceded, however, that the Federal Government itself ought to take a more active hand in the distribution of aliens, and in this connection Cunada, in advertising extensively for a north-west immigrntion and holding out inducements to the right kind of settlers, thereby gaining a splendid. agricultural population to till her wheat fields, is set forth as an object lesson and

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account