The Archive · 1908

The Moral of Museums

Some agitation is being made in Paris over the condition of the Louvre which, in spite of the fact that it almost sets "fashion for the museums of the world, "is said to suffer from a variety of abuses, which must be removed if the Louvre is to maintain its pre-eminence. Experts have decided for example that it is too big, conclusic with all deference tothe expert the plain man in the street came many years ago. Unfortunately this defect ix not to be overcome except by whole sale, rebuilding, for which the nation ix hardly prepared. Other experts, ho ever, do not think that the Louvre is big enough: there is no proper representation of architecture, they say, and although the cellars are fall of portfolios of marvellous designs they are never opened nor exhibited. Other experts jemand a wholesale reorganiza-weeding out. Much, they say, is lost to view amid more that is mediocre; and in the department of Greek sculpture in particular, the museum which boasts lion of the Wingless Victory of Samothrace and the Venus de Milo is encumbered with mass of marbles that are second class and in some cases, it is whispered, forgeries. Yet more experts suggest that the different forms of art are too much kept in watertight compartments. Pictures of the seventeenth century should be mingled with the furniture, embroidery and architect ture of the seventeenth century: then at least everything would be seen in its appropriate surroundings and the gain would be immeasurable. This criticism has the merit of being constructive; but even with such arearrangement, the treasures of the Louvre would suffer from the disability imposed on all museums, that they are not and never can be ours. The value of a work of art depends more than is generally recognized upon our possession of it, and a forest scene by an obscure painter which we cam have "for our very own" is more to us: for pleasure anil, to use a cant phrase, for educational benefit than the finest Constable in the National Gallery. In other words the moral of public museums is that they largely defeat their own object. For the great majority they are, perhaps, like the expensive libraries of the nouveau riches, a thing to boast about but not for nse. Even to the most enthusiastic devotees, museums fare often an undeniable disappointment. The visitor enters fall of pleased antici ud he comes out with a headache and a mouth full of yawns. If we are to preserve relics of the past,—and who would not?—let us keep them where they were first placed, the old houses, old diarches, with all that the centuries have bestowed on them, (here is a moral for the " devolationists" of church property in France), the old wrought iron gateways, the sacred picture under its little pent house at the street corner. It is better to wear out in the daily life of the world than tobe petrified in the No Man's Land of museum, THE PANAMA CANAL, An interesting side-light is thrown on Mr. W. H. Taft's complaint of the slow progress of the Panama which reference is made in our telegrams this morning, by some recent discloseres of the probable cost of the undertaking. As "The Outlook," to which we are indebted for the figures, remarks, "the Americans' experience differs only from that of the French engineers who failed in the effort to pierce the isthmus in this, that more energy and unlimited money are now thrown into the work." Atthe same time, and with all allowance for the present temper of the American people which appgara to be zealous for every project concerning the national defence, it is clear that the constraction of the Panama Canal is putting s severe strain on those who have undertaken it. At the beginning Congress was assured that the utmost sum that would be necessary to finish the canal was twenty-eight millions sterling. De Lesseps' first project, if we recollect aright, was to be covered by an expenditure of 640,000,000 frs. or, roughly speaking, £25,600,000; but this estimate was based on the cheaper though, sit proved, impracticable idea of " sea level canal. Now it is admitted that twenty to thirty millions more will be needed, and that even thir amount may not be sufficient, as much of the hardest part of the work, including the foundation of dams and locks, still remains to be done. Another anxiety, is caused by the fact that whereas the canal as at present designed will be deep enough for the actual type of American battleship, the tendency of naval constructors is now so munch for more powerful ships of deeper draught that the canal may have to be considerably deepened, anit obviously at great cost, before it can be thoroughly serviceable for any vessels but merchantmen: and the Panama Canal will not have repaid its cost unless it is an efficient asset in the national defence,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account