The Archive · 1916

The Question of Street Lighting

The lighting of streets in Shanghai, in other places, la " matter which calls for deliberation, particularly when one has to advise as to the rela merits of gas and clectricity—one commodity in the hands of a private Com pany and the other under the control of the Municipality.

From the outset one must be prepared to look at the question from a broad point of view and, with the experience already gained in' Shanghai, it la not too much te say that there are good points to be noted on both sides. It may equally be said that both sides have their disadvantages.

I think it requires little or no argu: ment to prove that in the matter of lighting, public or private, it is unwise to put one's eggs all into one basket. This has been recognized all over the world in connexion with theatres and public buildings. Some private houses in Shanghai are equipped with a dual aystem of lighting which will never be source of regret to the occupants. Looking at the question from a broader aspect, however, and having regard to the various causes which may interrupt tone service or another, it is not going too far to say that the lighting of the streets should be on the dual system. Experience in the typhoon at the end of July when the electricity supply fail: ed, mainly on account of its overhead wires, and many streets and houses were left in darkness for six days, presented contrast to those places where gas was prevailing illuminant.

The following extract from the Acting Electrical Engineer's Report of August 2, 1915, is of interest "Street Lighting.—The greatest dam age was caused to this lighting espec ly in the Western District, quite " num: ber of the lighting brackets were blown completely off the poles and wires broken in innumerable places. This series sys tem of street lighting, although being very convenient and cheap in many does not lend itself to quick repair work, as one break anywhere on circuit puts out' all the lights on tat circuit. There are at present 24 of these circuits some of them 3 to 4 miles long, can be easily understood the time required to go round each of them is very considerable. The Central, Eastern and Northern Districts did not suffer in the Western where getting the lights into in the Western District, has been very great and the failure of street lighting very serious...

Another instance, which however did not affect this Settlement. was on the night of the bombing raid in Frenchtown (December 6) when the wires were cut 709 and all electric lights went out in the neighbourhood of the trouble.

Gas lighting is perhaps not so prone to such interruptions, although high winds will frequently put lamps out.

The solution of the street lighting question is the installation of alternate gas and electric lights. I think the general principle must commend itself to all, but I would like to make suggestion in addition and that is that with lamps side by side, the gas and electreity enterprises would be put on their mettle in healthy competition both as regard the light produced and its cost—a very important point to the public.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account