The Archive · 1908

of Zimmerman

After farther argoment, Mr Fessencents ($51,973 28).

'And for a" farther and separate to plaintiffs' petition here ey den agreed to the counter-claim of defence the defendant alleges that the Sfofesaid contract of charter-party upon which ti is brought is frandalent, ill 1 void in that it appears fromthe jadgementof H.B.M.'sSupreme Court aforesaid, which judgement will be offered in evidence upon the trial of this action, that both before and at the time the said contract was entered into, constitute a defence to plaintiffs' suit, 2. That the facts alleged in paragraph two of' said answer do not constitute res adjudicate as therein alleged, and do not constitute a sufficient answer to plaintiffs' petition nor defence to plaintiffs' suit herein.

3, That the facts alleged in paragraphs three, four, five and $52,000 going out of the case.

His Honour said that the elimination of one of the plaintiffs from the case would change the defendant's answer materially; and the answer, wauld be changed on the other point where defendant alleged fraud as he. woald have to set out facts. His Honoor gave one day in which counsel for the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account