The Archive · 1908

His Worship (to Inspector Bourke)

I think this witness is telling lies, because he went upstairs.

Tnspector Bourke On whose eridence can you say that? Yon have! heard the corroborated evidence of these men and the Indian constable that he did not go into the house except s far as he was dragged in. In support of this statement his clothes, which have been mauled by the accused, have been produced. "I do not see why evidence should not be believed, as it is only nataral that the accused would try to make up a story for their defence. Even' if the police did enter the house, there would be no need to hide the fact, for they would have been Perfectly justified. It is a serious offence to give false evidence.

Police-Sergeant Moonan—I am able to state that Constable Batler novi left the charge room after he came in the first time.

His Worship—He in liable to prosecution for giving false evidence, Tnspector Bourke—I submit that it has not been proved that he is giving false evidence; I have evidence to rebut that put in for the defence. Yon have the evidence of the foreign constables which corroborates. witness" story. There is no doubt whater it His Worship—There are many witnesses besides the police.

Inspector Bourke—Yes, for the une is Worship—It you take that Attitude, he need not deny that he went upstairs, He had better speak the trath, Tnspector Bourke—There woald be no need for him to deny it if he went int" the tense.

His Worship—I cannot hear any more from this witnoas.

Inspector Bourke (to witness) Where were you on daty Witness—In Boone Road.

What attracted your attention? The blowing of a went round to the alley and was attacked by four men, including the proprietor of the house. The proprietor of the house tried to take my revolver away from me and I strack him with my baton, Then two foreign constables came to assistance and we arrested four of the accused and took them to the station, (Can you swear you never went into the house?—Yee, And that was the only time you went to the scene?—Yes, Inspector Bourke (to His Worship)—That is his vid T have not itis only the procedure of this Court but I know it ix not the procedure adopted in other Courts. It would not be allowed.

Police Constable Murray was next His Worship—How many times did yon visit the scene I arrested two men the second time I went there, Did yon enter the house?—No.

Where did you see Constable Butler?—Struggling in the door way. They were trying to take his revolver from him and also to pull him inside. went to his assistance and got him away. He did not go into the house for it would have been impossible to pass the four Japanese at the door, Did Constable Butler go round a second time?—No.

That man (pointing to one of the accused) says you arrested him upstairs 7—I did not. I arrested him at the corner of Boone Road and the alley' He was 60 drunk he did not know where he had been arrested.

His Worsbip—He says he was asleep in the room and that three constables came.

Inspector Bourke—Who said 40 is Worship—That ith an old man and his wife was there also. I think this witness is also giving false evidence.

Inspector Bourke—That is a very serious accusation to make against a policeman. It is the first time they have had fu accusation made against them in Court.

His Worship requested two sailors who were lined up with the accused to step out, and said—These two men are not accused (one of them in the captain's boy) and he says he saw these constables go up the stairs twice. He says that sailor (indicating one of the accused) was just soing downstairs when he was arrested.

sector Bonrke—How could he see him if he was in bed His Worship—He was not in bed.

Inspector Bourke—The fact of the matter is none of them know where they were arrested, they were drunk, Constable Wells said he assisted in the arrest of the accused, because they were assaulting Constable Butler. They were straggling in the alleyway when witness arrived on the "scene. Alter assisting in taking four Japanese to the station witness returned to the scene and found the Japanese shouting and arguing with each other. He told them to go inside but they would not.

His Hononr—Were you in the house?

Witness—No, I went to the door-to nnsixt oustable Butler and did to the house at all, rahip—He (pointing to one of the sailors) says that he was arrested by you upstairs Witness—I was never upstairs, Can he say how I was dressed His Worship—He says you were in uniform.

Witness—I wus not in fall uniform as Thad been in the creek about an hour previously and my uniform wax wet. I wore dark trousers and a policeman's tunic bnt wore no helmet, Inspector Bourke—This witness says he bad his uniform torn in the alleyway assisting Constable Butler. How, then, could Butler have been upstairs Witness—Constable Butler did not return with Hix Worship—I think that. statement is untrue, Inspector Bourke—It appears to me in this case, as in others of a nature that have been brought before the Court, after the evidence has been given by the complainants and police they are subject to a strict eros examination by the Court, ax if they were the defendants. It seems as though the police are actanlly the accused and the defendants are the aggrieved parties. I submit that the evidence has been given in a straightforward—manner time the _ricsha—coolie was, engaged and then assaulted, to the NE

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account