The Archive · 1924

Publication of Untruthfut Statements: Journalists' Responsibilities

appeared before Mr. Whitamore Six newspaper Chinese men

(British Assessor) and Magistrate Loh, at the Mixed Court on Saturday, charged with having published Aibelious statements against Sub-Inspector T. Dunne in cerine: with the Louza coolie case. The: statement "alleged that—_ the Tnspeetor had behaved in a cruel and barbarous manner, und had beaten the coolie to death, whereas investigation showed the death of the coolie was due to disease and not to a blow. The defendants:

Zung, Puo-Ini and Lee Tsung-woo, "shanghai Journal of Commerce," Hou Chien-ping (alias Jabin Hsu), and Sun Tsoong-woo "Shanghai Tribune," and Dib Tsao-thing and Chen Long-hyosh, "Eastern Times."

Mr. E, T, "Maitland, Police Prosecutor, conducted the' prosecu~ tion, and' defendants were re-Presented by Mr. A. M. Preston, Mr, H. D. Rodger, Mr. A. Covey and M. Premet. Mr, Reader Harris watched the case on behalf of Police-Sgt. Dunne, Mr. Arthur Covey, appearing for the relatives of the deceased coolie, informed the court that on. the previous day he made application to the Magistrate of the British Court for the issue of a warrant for the arrest of Sgt. Dunne upon a charge of doing grievous. bodily. harm, the relatives being the com: plainants, That application sub-judice, and points were raised which might call for the higher Court's decision. In the cireumstances, he asked that all cases then before the Court be ad-_ journed until the British Court had given its decision as to when ther. further charges against. Dunne could be proceeded with or not.

Mr, Maitland—You have no right to he here, the family having nothing to do with this prosecution, which is one by the Police, 'The Assessor the' Court would proceed with the case, reserving its decision if they. thought it likely to affect a judgment elsewhere.

Mr. Rodger then argued that the defendants were not subject to the jurisdiction of the Mixed Court. The "Eastern Times" was a French company with French money in it, and the "Journal of Commerce" was registered with of that?

Mr. Rodger—They accept jurisdiction over these companies.

Mr. Maitland pointed out that! defendants were, individually, being' summoned as newspaper managers and editors responsible for what} they published, and they were all Chinese and not registered at any other Consulate.

The Court decided to take Jurisdiction, and the hearing wa: proceeded with.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account