Sept. 11.
Nonoby, we are sure, was more amused than the Belgian colony of Shanghai, on learning that their Government had asked that they might take refuge on British men-of-war in case of necessity. But telegrams of this kind are rather tragic than comic, for they reveal how abysmal is the ignorance even of governments in the West of the true state of affairs in China. On the other hand, it is possible that we foreigners in China, if not ignorant about her, are not perhaps "always quite judicious towards her. For example, at the present time all sorts of proposals are in the air as to what the Powers should do in respect of the civil war now raging in China, These are born of excitement, of business anxiety, and of the well-founded feeling of the foreigner in China that he has suffered much injustice at Chinese hands in recent Chinese not less than by foreigners that what the Powers need most of all, what they have needed for many years past, is a clear-cut and consistent policy towards China. They tried sloppy, sentiment at the Washington Conference; they tried bluster and threats in the case of Lincheng; both have conspicuously failed, because neither was inspired either by. knowledge of facts or sincerity of purpose. There are certain requests and suggestions which the Powers have long been justified in advancing, and the present conflict undoubtedly gives them an opportunity to do 80, which should not be let slip. But if this opportunity is taken, it should be made very clear that there is no question of profiting by the misfortunes of the Chinese, but only that those misfortunes have brought home to Chinese of all classes the eminent advantage of proposals by which they themselves would benefit to an immeasurable extent more than the foreigners, Thus, for example, the urgent importance of removing the Woosung Forts and Kiangnan Arsenal from Shanghai. Millions, literally, of Chinese, would breathe a sigh of content if that were done, and Marshal Chi Hsieh-yuan himself suggested a year ago that it should be done. Again, the Powers cannot justifiably intervene by force to stop the Tuchuns from fighting each other. If the latter insist on fighting, it is their business and the Chinese people's and nobody's else. But the Powers might very well combine to invite the Tuchuns to join them. in a round-table conference with 'a view to ascertaining whether their differences cannot be adjust~ ed, and unification of China secured by peaceable means, as assuredly there are no signs of thei being achieved by force. But such © suggestion should clearly be advanced as an offer of friendly assistance, primarily in the interests of China, not as a matter of forcible intervention.
We hold, and are not in the Jeast afraid to say, that foreign Powers are not only justified in standing firmly on their treaty rights, while China continues in her present state of chaos, but that this chaos is very largely due to the fact that they have failed to do so. The Chinese people are) essentially reasonable and while they are in no way offended at one_ who sticks up for his proved rights, they feel nothing but contempt for him when he allows them to be filched away. It is perfectly possible for the foreign Powers in combination to uphold their rights in China—which fundamentally mean nothing more than freedom to live in China and do business peaceably as in other countries—and at the same time! to offer such suggestions and assistance to the parties of this d as will bring her relief and reform—which, indeed, multitudes of her people are convinced that she will never attain without such assistance from outside. But this combination of firmness and friendship demand that the Powers shall resolutely face facts in China as they really are, not as adroit propagandists or their own prejudice would have them be, shall say what they mean, and mean what they say. years without redress, or even the slightest symptom of regret on China's side.
The obvious fact that, for once in a way, both peoples and governments in the West have their attention now fairly directed towards China, naturally stimulates the desire, in the common phrase, "to get something done at last." The only practical result is confusion of
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.