The Archive · 1924

The Government China

Sept. 12.

IN the very interesting communication made to our correspondent by Mr. Tong Shao-yi, former Premier of China, it is frankly admitted that China has been on the wrong track ever counsel, and nothing done but to make the Chinese generally think that the foreigner means to make their misfortune his opportunity.

It will, we think, be agreed by since the revolution which over-threw the Manchu dynasty. He thinks the parliamentary system is unsuited to the Chinese people and that the whole present method of government is fundamentally: wrong. The constant civil wars.and general lawlessness amply justify his opinion. The political system he advocates himself seems to be that every province should' be practically self-governing, and that it should select, or choose by' lot, a representative or represent~ atives to combine with the representatives of other provinces to form a central administrative government. These representatives, or administrators as calls them, should be responsible only to their own provinces for! their conduct, not to any central authority, nor to the country at large. There should be a President, also chosen by lot. There should also be a permanent! Cabinet consisting of capable men, practically under the control of the administrators as the latter are to lay down general rules for the guidance of these permanent officials. He claims that this method of government is based upon history, tradition, the psychology of the Chinese people and common sense, With all respect it may be said that the political system outlined fundamentally weak: it pro-ides for no real federation of the provinces and gives no unifying, dominant authority. A President and legislative assembly elected by lot would certainly be a lottery of government, even if the lots; were drawn with the utmost fair~ ness and the candidates few.

With no public opinion or power of any kind behind it, such a government could never bring the turbulent military governors order, and a house divided against itself' cannot stand. As Confucius said:—

"There can be no properly constituted community without government; no government without subordination; no subordination without dominant authority. The recogni-precede the establishment of other (Gesirable) social conditions All history, whether foreign Chinese, indicates this necessity of a strong central government. It may be pointed out to our. Chinese readers that the Wars of the Roses in England (1456-_ 1485) furnish an instructive parallel to China's present condition. The English barons had so increased in power as to be able to defy the government of the king, Constantly intriguing and fighting amongst' themselves they eventually formed two opposing parties, Lancastrians and Yorkists, and a long war ensued.

"The consequent impotence of the government provoked a bastard feudal anarchy maintained ling: def factions fought with no respect for the law which was administered, if at all, in the interests of one " other great factions. No political, constitutional, or religious principle was at stake; and the more peaceable and organized parties of the com-ook little share in the Weakened by this warfare and with the social system disorganized by a frightful epidemic known as the "Black Death," the barons were finally subdued and the authority of the king was in time firmly established to the great and lasting benefit of. the country. Similarly in France, Richeliew (1585-1642) broke the power of the French nobles, being firmly convinced that the only safe government for France in its then condition was a monarchy uncontrolled either by the selfish ambition of the nobles or by the constitutional legalisms of the existing parliament. Granted that France, the United States, and many other countries are now Republican, yet the stability of government in each country depends entirely on how far the people have acquired by experience, perhaps long and painful, the wisdom necessary for successful self-government. is futile for China to try and establish a republic with the vast mass of the people illiterate, and ignorant of the bare meaning of such terms as republicanism and democracy. The first step towards unification and peace must be the subordination of the military governors to the central au-, thority; the civil government and civil law must be made supreme, In China the problems of government are the more complicated because down to the Revolution in 1911 religion and government were inseparably connected: the emperor was the political as well as the religious head of the people. In his sacred character it was he alone who was held capable of acting as mediator between the nation and the mysterious powers of the invisible world which bring prosperity and adversity, and he alone could offer propitiatory sacrifices for the whole country. Until the people find some other religious anchorage it seems almost necessary in their present condition that reigion should be again supported by the government. In the scheme proposed nothing is said on this most important point. Yet for ages the propitiation of these supernatural powers was deemed essential to the welfare of the people. During the long periods in Chinese history when turbulent princes and chieftains weakened the power and unity of the State by their insubordination, even then the emperor nominal authority served as bond of unity, because he was acknowledged' as the supreme fount of honour and as the sole regulator of the ceremonial and religious rites, The Chinese are in their present deplorable state because cut adrift from their religious and political moorings. It is no part of our purpose, however, to advocate any particular form of government. The country' must be left to work out its own salvation, But it may be regarded as a hopeful sign, amidst so much that is discouraging, that a statesman with the knowledge and experience of Mr. Tong Shaoyi gives expression to the general conviction that China made a grievous mistake in adopting a republican form of government for which it vas totally unprepared,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account