The Archive · 1920

PROFESSIONALISM NO LIBEL

July 17.

Lookers on proverbially see most of the game: and cynics will add that no one ought to know more about libels than a newspaper. On whichever score, we venture to think that there may be a good deal of disagreement with the learned Judge's decision that there was no libel in Captain Davies's advertising Mr. E. A. Dearn among the professional entertainers (so they presumably were) at the Cafe Parisien's Empire Day dinner. The case was, at least to spectators, specially interesting; and as the point at issue seems to have been one rather of opinion than law, the layman may make bold to have his say.

The essential part of his Lordship's decision is contained in the following sentence In order to be libellous, words must injure a man's reputation, and bring him into public ridicule and contempt. In this case the only meaning the words conveyed was that Mr. Dearn was a professional, whereas in fact he was not. Accordingly, his Lordship could no' see how the words could come within the definition of libel. He could not sce how they tended to bring by suggesting that he had joined Jaintiff into ridicule and contempt; the ranks of the professional performers.

Ridicule and contempt are rather strong words. Yet even going into no consideration beyond that here raised, one can conceive of Mr. Dearn suffering at least as much annoyance through the advertisement as has been held by juries, in some cases, to be good ground for damages.' Mr. Dearn is well known in Shanghai as en exceptionally good conjuror and ventriloquist, one of whom his friends have often been heard to' say "Really he's as good as a professional.'' The next thing that happens is the appearance of his name in a list of professional entertainers at a public restaurant.

Without the faintest derogation to the house in ques-iron, there is a wide difference between this and even the appearance of Mr. Dearn's name in a mixed programme of amateurs and professionals, say, for charity at the Lyceum. In a place like Shanghai. gossip begins inevitably. 'I see Dearn has turned pro.,"" says one. "Yes," says another, "I hear he's been meaning to chuck his job and go on the stage for a long time past.'" And the next version is that Mr. Impre Sano has offered him a twelve months contract with the Frivolinis. "Shouldn't have thought a chap like Dearn would have cared much about that sort of life,'' says one man rather contemptuously. All decidedly annoying and a "'loss of face," especially as we believe there are no amateurs so jealous of their amateur status as in the ranks of entertainers.

But another point might well be taken into consideration. The Cafe Parisien is one of those places of general resort, common nowadays in all big towns, where dancing is one of the chief attractions. We make not the slightest implication against it in saying this; but it is also well known that some people strongly disapprove of dancing whether in private or public rooms. It may be (we merely put a hypothesis) that Mr. Dearn has friends among such people, and it is easy to imagine the reprobation with which they would regard his not only aiding and abetting a public dancing hall with his entertainment, but (as it would seem from the advertisement) receiving money for doing so. Besides where is the line to be drawn? It may be no libel to suggest that Mr. Dearn is going to appear professionally at a public restaurant, but would it ibe equally baxmless to say the same of one of our well known lady amateurs? And if such an advertisement is harmless in respect of one unexceptionable house, what about another of less readily admitted respectability?

To be just to Captain Davies, one may be sure that he had not the slightest intention of giving offence. We do not know that he even intended to treat Mr.

Dearn as a professional. It is more than probable that in the bustle of getting ready for Empire Day he forgot the advertisement till the eleventh hour and then said to himself: Dearn won't mind, I can make it all right with him afterwards'' Finally, according to his counsel_to court, he seems to have written. a very ample apology. On the other hand, we do not imagine that Mr. Dearn was "out for' monetary consolation. What he wished to do was to set himself right in the eyes of the public and his friends, and that he has succeeded in doing, even though no libel was held to have been perpetrated, by the only means available to him. The only moral to be drawn is that it may be rather an expensive thing to go in for entertaining people—in more senses than one.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account