The Archive · 1920

The Vanity Girl

It is with genuine melancholy' that those who have hoped against hope that Mr. Compton Mackenzia's undoubted and remarkable: gifts as an observer would, some time, prevail against his' fatal facility and the inherent banality of his point of view must peruse his last novel. "The Vanity Girl" (Cassell, 8s. 6d. net) bears upon it every mark of library success: it has every passport to a big circulation; but artistically, as the work of @ writer in regard to whom Henry James once expressed the liveliest' anticipation, it does not exist. at all: it represents the abandonment of serious ini intention! altogether. It reminds one irresistably of a story by the late Frank Danby, which' "boomed" some ten or twelve years ago, "The Heart of Child."

Norah Caffyn—rather, Dorothy; Lonsdale, that being the name under which she entered the Vanity Chorus and finally married the: young Earl of Clarehaven—has not. got the heart of a child. She is, from. start to finish, a thoroughpaced worldling, with the calmly calculating selfishness, the nice adjustment of means to ends, of the successful adventurer—a rare creature only because success—-for the: female adventurer—spells the complete elimination or suppression of those awkward qualities convenient-Hhy Iunped together under the word "heart." But Mr. Compton Mackenzie, throwing away what might have been the one card in his hand, presents her not ironically, not} savagely, not with amusement or, with hatred, but with a good faith that seems at times to imply that he believes in her, is actually interested in her.

He has the ad-j} vantage, if this be so, of his. readers. To be interested in Dorothy is impossible. In so far: as she has. character at all, she is a perfect little cad, without the merit of knowing it. To see Mr. Mackenzie whimpering over her maternal agonies, heartbroken because the heir to the earldom miscarries, is really nauseating. Frank Danby carried off her impossible' young woman—who, if we remem-

By ber rightly, went one better than Dorothy in capturing a duke—by virtue of a kind of simple gusto and by giving to her one human quality—she was really, uncomfortably, in love. Dorothy is not: and yet nothing whatever is made of the fact. Clarehaven does not seem aware of it: it hardly strikes Dorothy. Mr. Mackenzie forgets about it.

Of course, since Mr. Mackenzie has the perfect art of the cine-motographist, the scene as it unrolls before us is admirably -and alertly diversified: it jumps and flickers just like the movies. There is very little he does not know about the Vanity Chorus; but after all, thanks to his own assiduous industry, there is very little we do

ay know either.

Are we never to a_rest from Lily Haden and la Scarlett? The Caffyn family do not provide any substantial relaxation; they belong to the furniture of the modern novelist and are not authentically seen at all. The young men are Mr. Compton Mackenzie's usual supers, and as for Mr. Leopold Hausberg, alias Lionel Houston, he is the merest melodrama. Although externally modernized, the story is in all essentials true to the type of the "Family Herald Supplement." Of-the kind }of vogue enjoyed in its time by that soothing syrup for the starved {romanticism of housemaids, nurse and typists, "The Vanity Girl? is wd; but of nothing more.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account