The Archive · 1928

The London Police Scandal

Officers Concerned in Questioning Miss Savidge Cleared London, July 18.

The majority report of the tribune appointed to investigate the: interrogation of Miss Savidge by Scotland Yard officers. signed by the Chairman of the Tribunal, Sir John Eldon Bankes, Lord Justice of Appeal, and Mr. J, J. Withers, a solicitor and Conservative M, P. for Cambridge University, holds the police responsible for bringing Miss Savidge to Scotland Yard, but does not hold the Director of Public Prosecutions blameworthy as he had followed an accepted practice: indeed the only practice open to him, The report goes on to state that in endeavouring to obtain a statement from Miss Savidge the later was not intimidated. While answering ques ons she was treated with no lack of propriety by Chief-Inspector Collins or Sergeant Clark and her answers were properly recorded. The report adds that it is impossible to accept her statements on material matters where there is a conflict of evidence between her and Inspector 'A¥ regards the action of the Chief Constable of the Criminal Investigation Department, Mr. F. Wensley, Superintendent Savage and Chief Inspector Collins in. bringing Savidge to Scotland Yard, the report finds that they were not blameworthy because they followed what apparently was an established practice but the application of the practice in this particular case is, disapproved, the report remarking Savidge should have been ap-Proached through her parents.

The minority report, signed by Mr. H, B. Lees-Smith, Labour M. P. for Keighley, says that the method of taking" Miss Savidge to Scotland Yard ix deserving of censure, the chief part of which falls on Chief-Inspector Collins and the minor share on Chief Constable Wensley and Superintendent Savage. because Miss Savidge was misled as regards the nature of the inquiry she would have to undergo. rds, the interrogation ard Mr. Lees-Smith cor Savidge was than either Inspector Collins or Sergeant Clark. 'The impression she made in the witness-box 'Mfrank, simple and childlike," whereas' "the mechanical precision with which the chief police witnesses corroborated every detail of each other's statement cast sus-piston on their evidence." Ho adds that the police asked Miss Savidge questions whi. h ought not have been asked and certain of her replies were foreed into a form misrepresenting, what she wished to say.

Mr. Lees-Smith says that grave perils to private citizens and civil Iiberty have been revealed by Miss Savidge's experience and concludes by suggesting fifteen questions with regard to the Scotland Yard system, 'a full reply to which wil need investigation into still wider fields concerning police administration and control.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account