Claim by Caldbeck, Macgregor's Against former Factory Employee: A Rival Concern An action to enforce a trade agreement entered into between employer and employee was begun in H.M. Supreme Court on Thurs day, before Sir Skinner Turner, Chief Judge, plaintiffs being Messrs. Caldbeck, Macgregor & Ca., Ld., and defendant Mr. R. B. Wood.
According to the statement of claim, plaintiffs, who are wine merchants and. manufacturers of aerated waters in Shanghai, in June, 1921, entered into an agreement with defendant, appointing him assistant factory manager for a term of three years, at a salary of Tls. 250, rising to Tls. 300. There waa a clause that the agreement might be determined on payment of three months' salary, and also the following clause, which was the niatter in dispute:— shall not during the shove ped "The assistant factory manager
tioned term or any prolongation thereof, or within 10 years from the expiration thereof, carry on or be concerned or interested in any capacity whatever, or in any manner whatsoever, in the like or any other trade, business or Occupaition whatsoever, whether profit or otherwise, either in China, Hongkong; Japan, Sing-spore, or the Straits Settlements; and in. case of any default in the Observance of the terms of this clause, he shall forfeit and pay to company the sum of $20,000 as ascertained and liquidated damages."
In; September, 1921, defendant wag appointed acting manager of the factory, at an increased muneration. His employment was terminated in August, 1922, and he "was paid three months' salary, and an additional voluntary payment of six months' salary. During the course of his employment, plaintiffs alleged, he had become cognizant of plaintiffs' wholesale customers and trade connexions, and @ acquainted with valuable secret re-cipos for the manufacture of aerated waters and other trade: secrets the property of plaintiffs and used them in their manufacturing business. In breach of this agreement, defendant, on January 1 of this year, entered the service of Waitson's Mineral Water Company, a Chinese company carrying on the business of aerated water manufacturers in. North Szechuen Road, and was still in their employment. Plaintiffs accordingly claimed an injunction restraining defendant for a period of 10 years from carrying on or being concerned in any capacity whatever in the business of the distilling and manufacture of aerated waters, whether for pro-
In defence, it was urged that the restrictive provisions in the agreement were an unreasonable and secretary and general manager, was called, and stated that, so far as he krew, his company were the largest unnecessary restraint of the defen-aerated water manufacturers la dant's freedom to trade, and were China; their goods were distributed, contrary to public policy, and throughout China To a very large illegal. extent, the recipes used were their For plaintiffs, it was stated that own property. They were impro'e-the "other trade secrets" referred ments, and in some respects coL-to were such matters as the prices siderable improvements, upon ¢ ther of ingredients, the sources from recipes, and were not to be found which they are obtained, bottles and jin books published by the trade. other gear used by the factory, and These secrets would ba known to the all matters connected with the meth-manager of the factory and hiy asod and cost of manufacture. As sistant, bub not outside. Witness regarded the specific waters for the first knew defendant when he was manufacture of which plaintiffs had employed at the Grand Hotel. He secret recipes, this applied to all afterwards became secretary of the waters manufactured by them, the Charity Orgamization Society, and most valuable being Aquarius water, Wae working in that capacity when Fosferado, Sanus water, dry ginko joined plaintiffs' firm. Witness ger ale, tonic water and ginger thought defendant would have got beer. to know their wholesale customers, and also the people from whom in-Mr. M. Reader Harris appeared gradients were obtained. When he for plaintiffs, and Mr. R. N. Mac left the firm, defendant applied leod for defendant. for permission to join Watson's SECRETS LEARNED BY HEART, Mineral Water Ca. and this wag refused. There was no clause in the In his opening, Mr. Reader Har-agreement with regard to consent ris said the facts of the case were in such circumstances. Defendant largely admitted. The secret re-was informed that plaintiffs would cipos were dictated to defendant, object, and would strictly enforce who took them down in a book and the agreement. Witness considered learned them by heart. They were that this restrictive clause was of great value to plaintiffs. De necessary for the protection of fendant had had no previous ex-plaintiff's business, perience of the work, and when he In cross-examination, Mr. Mac-left them he entered the service of leod suggested that, when. plaintiffs the Municipal Council. In Decem-claimed that defendant had got to ber last, he wrote asking plaintiffs' know the names of all their custom-permission to join Watson's Miners "in China," they were exag-eral Water Ca., and permission gerating enormously. was refused.
Witness said that r&&ghly, 100 His Lordship:—Isn't the agree-outport customers were supplied ment a very wide one in seeking direct from Shanghai. Their busi-to keep a man out of the business in ness With Hongkong was only emall the places named for a period of Singapore was negligible, Japan 10 years? about the same, anda very small Mr. Reader Harris—No doubt it business wag done with the Straita, is wide.—Counsel added that he was owing to the distance. not seeking an injunction primar-Mr, Macleod—Do you seriously ily. If the court held that defend-suggest that defendant had opport-aut could do buginess at certain unity of gaining such influence over places, then he claimed damages. your customers og to be able to {t was not possible to contract an divert business from you after he employee against competing, but it left? Did he have any real rela-was possible to contract against tiang with them at all?
Witness—No. such unfair competition as was involved in the usa of trade secrets.
Mr. Macleod—He knew nothing It all depended upon whether the about the prices you charged competition was unfair. A man Witness—He would only see the was entitled to use his skill and ordinary price list.—In one or two brains, but he could be restrained cases, witness added, ° defendant) if he got knowledge of another would know the. cost of production. man's trade secrets and attempted Mr. J. Sheridan, plaintiffs' to use them against him. manager, stated that about 150 customers were supplied direct from Hig Lordship—You boldly allege as "trade secrets'? things which can hardly be held to be trade secrete—the cost of materials, for instance.
Reader Harris—Cost and source. The source where the mat-
Shanghai. On_ several occasions, defendant had been sent to see the firm's biggest Chinese dealer in Shanghai. The recipes which were dictated to him by witness were quite secret. © Witness considered enol comes from is secret.
His Lordship—Is it?
Mr. Reader Hairris—It may be of importance to rival manufacturers to know where we get our in-gradients.
His Lordship—You have got to have something very special in a business before you can prevent an employee selling his knowledge elsewhere, even if it is fo a rival, the most valuable were Acquarius water, Sanus water, sarsaparilla, ginger beer and lemonade. 7
ness said he did not suggest ti In. answer to Mr, Leet fendant had got in touch. with the firm's biggest "Chinese "dealer in such, a way og to get the business from him.
Mr. Macleod—The difference between your manufactures and' thoes
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.