The Archive · 1923

POST-WAR ENGLAND

Exouaxp Arren War~-A Srvps. By The Right Hon, Charles F. G. Masterman, Hodder & Stoughton. 10/6 net.

This book is handicapped in a somewhat strange way, by the fact of its author being a very well known public man. It is probably; safe to say that it would have had' a very large circulation if it had been written by an absolutely uaknown person. For it is a good book; it is not far short of a great one. It is the most faithful picture of the condition of Eng-jand that has been published since the war. And it will not have anything like the circulation that it deserves for the simple fact that the author's name will make the reading public imagine that it is some kind of axe-grinding. Not that any of Mr. Masterman's previous utterances have given rise to any euch suspicion; but merely that he is a member of Parliament, that home of compromise, in whose spacious yard the imaginative see the smoke constantly ascending from the holocaust, the sacrifice of ideals. So that a man has but to have the initials "M.P." after his name for any writing of his to suffer the same reception as the press of his party It becomes the object of indiscriminate, undiscerning praise of those of the party of his allegiance, and it is looked en with suspicion as to its honesty or singlemindedness by the great majority of the reading public. This book is bound to suffer such a fate. It is of little use to say it is a book that should be read of all; that it possesses qualities that Place it far out of the range of anything in the nature of propaganda. It is of little avail for Mr. Masterman to say, as he does, in his preface:

"And in this volume, as in the case of its predecessor, I would like to be five that the work is one of detachment that I am examining. impartially end disinterestedly, a world in change and thet no one would be able to ascertain from theee pages what my actual political and social opinions were, or to which, if any, party in the State I owed Mr. Masterman's disability is in the fact that he is placed in a position which should ensure his universal hearing, but which, as a fact, makes anything he may write—suspect. One may say that is one of the drawbacks of the party system of gover, it, that every utterance of our*legislators, when hbearkened to at all, is examined,—for the most part unfairly,—for the compromise, for the exaggeration, for the spiritual sacrifice to some party material gain. Bunt the Coalition inspired no greater confidence, and, indeed, may be

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account