The Archive · 1923

The Boxer Indemnity

To the Editor of the "Nortu-Cuina Dairy News."

Sin,—Mr. Herbert L. Beer, in his letter of Feb. 22, appearing in your issue of yesterday's date, puts forward -a specious plea for the allocation of some portion of the balance of the Boxer Indemnity for the education of British children in China, but, in common with the advocates of this pernicious proposal, he appears to be unaware of, dr to overlook two important facts. The first is, although H. M. Government has agreed in principle that the balance due, £11,186,547, should be devoted to interests "mutually beneficial" to Britain and China, the proposal has yet to.be approved by Parliament. The word "remission" in connexion with the proposed allocation of a sum of money. equal to the balance of the Boxer Indemnity is distinctly a misnomer, as the money has first to be collected, by. Great Britain and then voted in the annual estimates as expenditure, a step the House of Commons as at present constituted is most unlikely to take, especially in view of the financial stringency at Home.

The second point is with regard to the ownership of the balance due to Great Britain. It may come as a surprise to Mr. Beer, and other of your readers, fo Know that the money is the sole property of the Home taxpayer. The salient point about Great Britain's share of the Indemnity is that it was not of the nature of a fine or penalty, but represented the nett cost to Great Britain of her share of the naval and military operations during the rising, plus the amount required to compensate British nationals operations was, of course, paid at the time by the British Treasucy, and all claims for compensation made by British civilians were also met by the British Government against Bonds issued' by the Chinese Government. The Peking Government, in its habitual state of bankruptcy, could not meet its obligations and Great Britaia, together with the other Powers, magnanimously allowed her to spread the redemption of the Bonds over a number of years, until 1940 to be precise. The British share of the Indemnity, therefore, became nothing more or jess than a loan to the Chinese Government.

The whole proposal that Britain should give £11,186,547 to education in China is morally and economically rotten to the core. Why should Great Britain, staggering under a National Debt of £180 per head of population, be asked to devote over eleven: million pounds towards the educational projects of a country with a debt of but 10/0 per head? And at a time when Great Britain hag beea compelled to drop her national housing scheme for want of funds, when her own educational system is being. seriously jeopardized owing to financial stringency, and when a million and a quarter of her people are unemployed and probably three times as many more are on the verge of starvation. But this question has, a long way to go before a single cent of the money is spent in China; if will almost certainly get its quietus on the floor of the House of Commons, no. matter how secret its sponsors, the merchants, sinologues, and pro-Chinese Britishers may try to keep it Can Mr. Beer advance any good reason why the British taxpayer, who has to finance his own educational schemes and pay for the education of his own children, should give £11,186,547 towards the education of Chinese and the children of rich merchants and their well-paid assistants?

I am, ete., Britisa Taxpayer.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account