The Archive · 1923

UNPALATABLE FACTS

With these various statements, which serve to summarize Section Mr. Padoux establishes his premises. They are statements of simple fact, which no one with the slightest knowledge of China would attempt to controvert. They embody facts, however, which all Chinese officials of this generation, high or low, with very rare exceptions, make the most strenuous effort to evade. The rupture of the eld system of mutual accountability between the provinces and Peking has brought China (or rather the Government) to the verge of bankruptcy and! the only fundamental solution of the financial muddle which anyone who understand the cause of the trouble could suggest would be a restora-tien of a system of mutual accountability. All the new official prerogatives and new traditional abuses of power which have grown up under the Republic are grounded in the rupture of the old system: and the re-establishment of the old system or of a new system of accountability, equally or more effective, would break down all the new official prerogatives and the rotten official traditions which the Republic has fostered. Therefore, ne official having money to handle will sincerely endorse a system of mutual accountability, while loans, bond issues, misappropriation of taxes, sale of offices. and alli the ultra-modern banker's sleight-of-hand imported from abroad will nestpone a fundamental reform. There is also no denying that, in these evasions of a real statement and readjustment, Chinese official dom hae been. encouraged by the example, if not by the deliberate instruction. of foreign fin-anders, Tt is diffeult to find in Peking a. foreigner seasoned in financial jugglery with the Chinese Government who can be made to see that any measures of expediency which do not tend directly to restore a Government enjoying—authority over the provinces and the con. fidence of the provinees, which ders not tend to force the restoration of seme such system, only serves te shove China a little nearer the brink.

Mr. Padoux's opening section, which we may assume to embody the premises of his argument for the funding scheme, proves him an exception. He does see the fundamental cause of China's troubles and he does prescribe the ultimate cure. Since he goes to the trouble of prefacing his argument for debt consolidation with these premises, we are warranted in inferring that he looks upon his funding scheme as a feasible means to this ultimate cure. This he does not specifically state, but unless this is implied the introductory section is pointless. In Peking there are a number of high authorities who, since the publication of Mr. Padoux's memorandum, have enthusiastically endorsed it, pointing out that if the Chinese at. the prospective international tariff conference were cajoled or forced into agreement with this scheme, li would dispose of all their available revenues, securities and credits at one fell swoop and force the provinces in turn to support a Central Government if the provinces really wanted one. With this the writer does not agree. He does not believe that this end would be attained at all and_ therefore does not - believe that Mr. Padoux's scheme would lead directly or indirectly to the fundamental solution. The reasons for this lack of faith will be detailed later.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account