Whether the pressure is exerted from without or within, it will be ineffectual to force reform from the top down while Peking can collect revenues outside the capital without accounting for them to the provinces and while Peking can negotiate loans. To force the creation of institutions in Po king which would make the Government responsible to the people and the provinces, the first essential is to put an effective ban on loans and the second is to withhold revenues collected from the people for which Peking is under no obligation to render an account. The first of these is an old proposition, the second has not been generally discussed Virtually the only revenues which Peking receives or is likely are the surpluses of Salt and Customs revenues over and above loan services upon which the Ministry of Finance cannot default. As the editor of the "North China Daily News" has pointed out, the release of such surpluses to the Peking Government, without the consent of the provinces which do not recognize Peking, constitutes and will always constitute a real grievance against the foreigner. Without the foreigner these revenues would never reach Peking. Whatever motives we may believe inspire most of the provincial leaders in recalcitrant Provinces, we can never give an adequate answer to our critics who say that by force majeure we are abetting Peking in "taxation without representation." While all Anglo-Saxons now unite recognizing that this was good and sufficient reason for the secession of the American Colonies from the British Empire, we have to do a lot of explaining to show why it is not good and sufficient reason for the secession of Chinese provinces. The responsibility for this condition of course devolves upon our various Governments which continue to recognize whatever rules the city of Peking as the Government of China, and as a "Republican" and "representative" Government at that. The foreigners who control tax collection for foreign debt services would be adopting a very highhanded policy, _in which they would have no Legation support whatever, if they withheld Peking revenues just because we and they all think that Peking is not fit to administer them.
This does not make it any less apparent that these revenues should be withheld and should continue to be withheld until Peking's administration of. them (and of all other revenues for that matter) were controlled by all China and until Peking, through the establishment of a real board of audit whose published accounts would be in good faith and which would have the guaranteed right of the most rigid inspection of all departmental] expenditures. spent _its income properly. The withholding of loans and of all other free money over which the foreigner has direct or indirect con#rol, would obviously be subject to the same conditions.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.