The Archive · 1923

Finding in Favour of Defendant at H. M: Supreme Court on

Tuesday, Sir Skinner Turner gave judgment in favour of Mr. R. B. Wood, against whom his former employers, Messrs. Caldbeck, Macgregor & Ca, brought an action to enforce the terms of an agreement restraining him from engaging in any capacity in the mineral water business in the Far East for a period of 10 years. Alternatively, plaintifis sought damages to the amount of $20,000 on the ground that, during his term of service with plaintifis, defendant gained a knowledge of secret recipes and might use them in the trade te the detriment. of plaintiffs.

Mr. M. Reader Harris appeared for plaintiffs, and Mr. R. N. Mae-leod for defendants.

His Lordship's judgment was 26 _follows:—In this case Messrs. Caldbeck Macgregor & Ca., Ld., manufacturers of aerated waters, ask for an injunction restraining the defendant Wood from entering into certain employment in Shanghai as being a breach of a covenant entered into by him in June, 1921. It is not denied that the defendant has entered into the employ of another manufacturer of aerated waters in Shanghai. The defendant pleads that the covenant sought to be enforced is too wide and unreasonable and therefore is not enforceable in law. The plaintiffs reply that even if the original covenant is too wide (as indeed they admitted) it can be severed and effect must be given to the severed part.

The facts are short: the plaintiffs are well-known manufacturers of these waters with a trade cent nexion throughout the coast ports of China, up the Yangtze and West Rivers and in Hongkong. In their business they make use of certain secret recipes, which are dictated to the foreign employees in the factory and memorized by them. There are only some five other manufacturers of these waters in China. The plaintiffs' factory is in Shanghai. The defendant is now a man of some 50 years of age and 97 years in China. Originally at sea, he afterwards became manager of a steam laundry, the secretary. of the Charity Organiza tion Society and then manager of an hotel. In 1917 he joined the plaintiffs as an assistant manager ju their factory here without any written agreement. At that time he had no peculiar qualifications for the manufacture of these waters. In June, 1921, he entered into a written agreement dating back to January, 1920, to serve the plaintiffs as an assistant factory manager. He served under that agreement as an assistant manager and acting manager till the termination of his agreement, as provided, in 1922. He then obtained employment in the Electricity Department of the S.M.C. and at the beginning of this year he entered the service of Watson's Mineral Water Ca., a Chinese corporation carrying on a rival business here in Shanghai. This is the breach complained of. He had previously asked the plaintiffs for sanction to do so and been refused.

The material parts of the agreement are as follows. It is made between the company and the defendant as the "assistant factory manager." The defendant was to serve in the capacity of assistant factory manager of the factory and works belonging to the company at Shanghai for distilling and the manufacture of aerated waters for a term of three years. His remunerations are then set out, and there is a provision for termination of the agreement by the company at any time on payment of three months remuneration, Then follows "The assistant factory manager shall during his continuance in the said employment obey all the lawful directions of the company either in the conduct of the said business or otherwise in relation thereto and shall keep all accounts which they may require ani should the company desire his services in their general wine business there or elsewhere instead of in the aforesaid factory he shall undertake to conform to and obey their directions in any capacity im which they may require his services to the best of his ability. The assistant factory manager shall not during the above mentioned term or any prolongation thereof or within 10 years from the expiration thereof carry on or be concerned or interested in any capacity whatever or in any manna whatsoever in the like or any other trade business or occupation whatsoever whether for profit or otherwise and either in China, Hongkong, Japan. Singapore or the Straits Settlements. And in case of any default in the observance of the terms of this clause he shell forfeit and pay to the company the sum of $20,000 as' ascertained and liquidated Then there is a provision for dis missal in case of incapacity, ete., and further provisions for the re newal of the agreement.

No suggestion is made of any compulsion on the defendant to sign such an agreement, but it is noteworthy that the defendant had served for some four years without any agreement at all or any sug gestion of a restraining covenant, and during that time he had learn: ed the secret recipes of the plaintiffs and had had the same opportunities of getting to know their customers as existed from June,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account