The Archive · 1923

RIVAL GARAGES

In outlining the case for the prosecution, Mr. Kentwell said that the charge was brought under Articles 382 and 383 of the Chinese Criminal Code, and as he anticipated that the. defence would {state that this case was a matter [for civil and not criminal proceed-the $25,000, the prosecution sail a ings. he would point out that that because this sum was paid criminal proceedings were justified into defendant's account about 2 because defendant by an overt act certain date, it must therefore be} had obtained Y. 4.000 from com-half of the $50,000 alleged to have' plainants by fraud It appeared been fraudulently obtained; On that complainants and defendant October 19, 1921, defendant was not entered into some sort of written an official of the Exchange. To be-agreement by which defendant was come one he had to acquire a cer-to purchase motor cars in number of shares, and for this pur-Vladivostok for the complainants. pose he borrowed $25,000 from'

Though the money was actually Nien, Nien about that time drew received by the defendant in on one of the hanks for Tls, 39,000, Vladivostok, both parties were now and the $25,000 was from that) in Shanghai and. he submitted. source, That $50,000 had nothing under the jurisdiction of the whatever to-do with any Consular Mixed Court here. The defendant fees. The evidence for the prose-might contend that he was a part-caution was purely deduction ner and therefore this should be a and inference. If the $50,000 civil action, but Counsel hoped to was received as alleged—by show that it was a criminal case the prosecution, surely they could according to the Articles he had bring evidence to' show where quoted. He hoped to be able to came from. The defendant had prove to the Court the criminal given the officials of the Exchange) intent of the defendant, as shown a fair estimate of what the fees for by his acts subsequent to his receipt registration would be, He estimat-of the Y. 4,000. Defendant, after ed about $14,000 on a capital of receipt of the complainants' five millions. so that on a capital money, had shipped cars and acof 20 millions the estimate worked cessories to the Royal Garage Ca., out at $56,000, and this was not of which he was now the manager, far away from the actual figures and for this purpose had used com-Everybody concerned, therefore, plainants' money. In September must have known roughly what the of last year a credit of Y. 4,000 Consular fees would amount to. was opened with the Yokohama On the documents before the Court.

Specie Bank -at Vladivostok. Deand on the evidence, Counsel asked, fendant proceeded to Vladivostok, that the charge be dismissed. and and immediately upon his arrival in the event of this request being there, withdrew this money from refused, asked that the Court the bank. His duties, according should issue a subpoena for the to the agreement, were to buy attendance of Mr, Sugiura and the motor cars for the complainants, production of the documents he had, but instead he bought cars and accalled for. cessories for the Royal Garage, Mr, Yano replied briefly, and the and these' he shipped in his own Court adjourned the hearing until) name and not in that of the com-such time as the complainant, Mr. Sugiura, should be able to appear on subpoena, plainants. He shipped to the complainants a Hupmobile car that had evidently been in the

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account