The Archive · 1926

THE MAGISTRATE'S JUDGMENT

A translation of the Magistrate's Judgment is as followa:—In this case I and Mr, A. D.

Blackburn, British Assess of the factory in number of their shares, in accordance with the custom of partner. Ship at Shanghat and judgment was duly delivered.

In September, 1923 counsel for plaintiffs filed a motion, In November, 1925, an order was made for further argument by Counsel on the question of the liability of the shareholders in unregistered ompans, with pattiedtar reference fo" the beating of the decisions fourth year Appeal Case No. 1543, seventh year Case No. 823 and Becond year Appeal Case No. 64, and Shanghai customs on this question.

There were several hearings and the question was exhaustively discussed and witnesses called by counsel for both parties to give evidence.

The Proportion of Liability The question to be decided by the Court is whether the solvent share-debts in proportion to the of shares they hold, or whether they are also, in proportion holdings, to bear the liabi those shareholders who are without Counsel for the plaintiffs in the course of his argument, referred to a number of decisions of the Supreme Court as precedents, third year No, 222, fourth year No. 2282, third year No. 292, third year No. 550, fourth year No. 68, fourth year No. 1543, fourth year Ni fourth year 2098, fourth 1789, fourth year 2145 and sixth' year Gi4 and maintained that the solvent partners of the defendant factory must be responsible in proportion to their shares for the Hiabilities of those shareholders who fare insolvent or have absconded. He further stated that I and Assestor Blackburn cannot have thoroughly appreciated the decisions of the Supreme Court quoted and that if they had been thoroughly appreciate ed we could not have given the decision we gav He also quoted cases in which decisions were given previously by other magistrates and assessors, of c: which the clearest is the case of Barlow & Ca., v. Mo Ching-thing and Lo Sung-jung and all of which followed decisions of the Supreme Court and show that the solvent shareholders of the defendant factory are responsible in proportion to their shares for the liabilities of those shareholders who are insolvent or have absconded.

He further stated that the Shang. hai custom quoted by counsel for papers connected with the application for registration, contained counterfoils for shares, various ae count hooks, chops, bills, ete.

The further hearing was: adjourn. the defendant was unreasonable and that if a decision should be given in accordance with that custom the well-being of Chinese and foreign commerce would be gravely affect.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account