The Archive · 1924

Deliberate Traffic Obstruction

Unvsual Case in Police Court Diemissed for Lack of a By-Law Dismissal of an offender because the offence had deliberately been committed was the curious result of a case at HM. Police Court on Thursday, when Mr.

Willder was ' summoned by the French police for having obstructed (raffle on the French Bund by placing his car actes, thu tram, lines and allowing it to remain there for seven minutes.

P. C. Pantrazi gave evidence that shortly after 0 o'clock on the night of the 6th instant he saw defendant's car standing across the: tram lines opposite Messageries—Maritimies offices, defendant himself standing in the road and holding an alterontion with the conductor of the tram car, Ho wanted to hit the conductor, but witness prevented him, and' ordered him—to, move his car away, which he @fd, WIN THE MOTOR MAN SWORE, Defendant expinined that ay ho was drawing thig eat out, from the pavement to take it to. the garage the tram cut came along and the motor man swore at him, twice. Having stopped at the and of Rue clu Consular, the tram Jear was about to proceed again when witness called out "man man." The driver. started. the tram car, however, and in order to prevent him going forward, witness turned -his oar on to the rails Worship—You were taking ar k, weren't your Defendant—A "little, bub the tram cay had scoteely moved when T did it, I hold him up Deenuse T could not see hi num ber in the dark, looking at the traffic regulation on which the summons wat based, fis Worship observed that. it referred to any obstruction "caused by negligence," and pointed out to the French Tnspector in charge of the case that this offence had been deliberately committed.

DEFENDANT Not NraLIGENT, The Inspector—Yos. But there wag an obstruction of traffic.

The Magistrate—Quito so, But your by-Jaw says "by their negli gener." You cannot say dos fendant in thig case was "nog: ligent." Ho was deliberate, not negligent. T think he was wrong, and if he had got his ear damaged he would only have himself to T understand that.

Naturally, T would not awe done it hil the the tram car bren going at any speed.

His Worship-—-T. cannot say the defendant has been negligent. Is any other by-law whielt woald cover. this. cate The "Inspector This Net, is thw only one His Worship—Are you quite contain there is no other article than Article 6, which says dri of vehicles must avoid obstruction of, traffic "by their negligence."

The Inspector—I did nob understand the circumstances of the ease when the report was His Worship—Well, Tam bound to fellow the Taw, and however wrong defendant' was, he has net" brought himself within this regulation: T shall have to disttiies the case legally, but T must say defendant was in the wrong, and if the Police Inspector could have given me any other regulation under which T ould enter a conviction T should: do_s0.

The case was than dismissed.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account