July 20.
The report received by the British Minister from Nanking on the result of the so-called "joint and strict investigation' of the disappearance of Mr. Thorburn docs not deserve the compliment of critical examina tion. It is not even c creditable or competent work of fiction. Its air of make-believe is so naively elementary. Its evasions are so. gross, its studied disregard of the weighty evidence furnished by the British authorities is so insulting that it is amazing that the Ministry of Foreign Affairs with which the relations of the British Minister nave been so cordial should have had the assurance to treat it as a document for serious consideration. Although of a piece with the general tenor of the communication, it would have been better if the Government had refrained. from adding the gratuitously provocative—information that instructions to search for Mr. Thorburn had been issued to the officials of certain provinces. The record of the ease in the six weeks of its development shows a continual attempt on the part of local officials eliminate 0
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.