The Archive · 1931

Eyes on Germany

The spectacle of a great nation faced with a crisis of extreme gravity is disturbing the financial and political senses of the. world. The disturbance is not created purely by the intensity of the crisis itself. Germany's plight would, it is true, demand the sympathy of other nations its own merits. Nations however are not inclined any more than individuals to allow sympathy to drive them to extremes. They can be generous but generosity in national as well as in international dealings is severely circumscribed. The reason why on both sides of the Atlantic there is an urgent desire to "do something"

Germany is because it is realized that Germany's undoing would in all human probability inflict immeasurable disaster on an already sorely distressed world, At the same time, without being callous, it is essential to weigh up the exact implications of the financial crisis to the relief of which President Hoover has so generously and prudently pledged the resources of the United States of America. The victim of financial stringency must convince her would be helpers that she is not ex-plaiting her apparent helpless: ness and that assistance given would be properly applied. The process of instituting inquiries of this, kind blooded; indness in the long run, atters of private charity the indiscriminate dispenser funds is a danger, The most beneficent responses to appeals are those which carefully asse: the actual financial cireumstances of each case and make the award arrietly comparable, with the ascertained need. It is ral that Germany should ive in the hour of her ne considerations of this ind are taken into account, It is just as natural that creditors like France should be inclined to adopt a critical attitude, The difficulty in such a crisis lies in the weakness of human nature which in a spirit of self-defence is apt to take advantage of an upheaval to make dispositions of funds to the greater accentration of the factors of disruption. These idiosyncrasies are clearly at work in Germany at the monient and are seriously hampering her financiers in their efforts to prevent collapse.

The reaction from the buoyant note struck when President Hoover made his momentous announcement may seem to be depressing. Mitigation of this renewal of gloom may be found. first in the clear statement from White House that the situation is regarded as more hopeful. The advantage taken of the first rapture of the markets by speculators naturally brought in its train a more subdued note which reawakened visions of despair, It should however be realized that the spirit of self-preservation alone would impel Germany to make every possible use of the respite now offered. In her own interest she would desire to avoid the catastrophe which, however, damaging to her' neighbours, would primarily flict her.' The meeting of the Foreign Ministers of the European Powers and the visit to Europe of Colonel Henry Stimson should ensure confidence calculated to encourage, the Banks on whom the main responsibility now rests to put forth their best efforts to meet the situation. The important message from Reuter's correspondent at Washington indicates that the United States: of America is very properly treating the problem as mainly financial, She is refusing to be drawn into political arguments. In other words, Germany must satisfy banking experts that she is taking reasonable financial measures for the stabilization of her position before the Federal Reserve Board will consider the possibility of coming to her relief, Much will depend on the Conference to be held in London next Monday. Whether it will bring nearer an attempt to modify once again the scale of reparation payments remains to be seen, It should be remarked that the economic history of the last twelve months—to go no further back has taught lessons and furnished experience which might readily transform—_previcusly, conceived ideas_on the whole debt position. In 1919 the German Government offered a sum which falls short to-day by very little of that accepted by her creditors in 1929-30 under the Young Plan, Her offer of that distant period was rejected. It might be an ironical discovery of the future if the figure ultimately established removed the margin between 1919 and 1929 altogether. 'The key tothe puzzle lies in' the extent to which the various nations have profited by the bitter experiences of the years in between, Dark as the outlook is to-day it can at east be said that it is facilitating appreciation of thi basic factor in the relationship of Europe with America, For Great Britain who, in sufficiently unenviable financial position already, stands to lose on the current Budget a matter of £11,000,000 by her adherence to the' Hoover Plan, coupled as it is with the postponement for twelve months of the payment of war debt annuities by the Dominions, the outlook is grim. There is plenty of confidence in the people despite the heaviness of the burden to be shouldered, Confidence is not enough nor is the general optimistic feeling that a turn of the tide of trade depression is in sight. An end must be put to the hectic mounting of expenditure out of all proportion to the revenue obtainable. It is most regrettable that at this juncture all three political parties seem inclined to shirk the conclusions of th Majority Report of the Royal Commission on the Unemployment Insurance Fund. All eyes ave on Germany at the moment. 'There is a danger that this strained expectation may divert attention from the drain which the national finances are now enduring owing to the fact that the State is lending to the Fund at the rate of $50,000,000 annum, 'The Fund' may, be an insurance against revolution but at that figure the premium is 80 high as to portend revolution of itself, Apart from that the Government having called in, highly qualified physicians to diagnose the complaint and having been given diagnosis of alarming gravity are afraid to apply the prescribed remedy. Their opponents are not a whit more courageous, Thus the natio steadily heading for a crisis which may well be brought to a head by the latest shrinkage in the national resources, While the plight of Germany is engaging the present attention of the world, it should not be forgotten that, 80 far as available figures show, the trade depression in that country is not much worse than in the United States or in Great Britain. In Great Britain hopes for ending that depression are not likely to be fulfilled less there is a serious attempt made to tackle the issues presented in the crushing burden of taxation and the accompanying threat of insolvency which the drain of the Insurance Fund surely provides, In other words the medicine which Australia has been urged to take may have to be dispensed in Great Britain at no very distant date.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account