Mr. Maguire's letter depends entirely on the truth or otherwise of the assumption contained in three words that he uses: '"'absolutely necessary improvements." He thinks it is necessary for the solation of Shanghai traffic problems that we should spoil the design the Public Gardens and cut down valuable trees. We emphatically do not—for the good reason that it is not a question of opinion but of fact. So long as the Garden Bridge remains unwidened and the buildings immediately north of it immovable, the hundred and_ fifty ards of road alongside of the ublic Gardens are ample for all the traffic that can simultaneously enter or debouch from the bridge. To suppose that widening that road will afford any perceptible relief is about as sensible as to expect that clearing out a gutter will relieve a stoppage in the piping from the roof. We know nothing about Morrison Hill in Hongkong, nor do we care, because it has nothing whatever to do with the Public Gardens in Shanghai. It will be time enough to cut into them when the Garden Bridge is widened and the buildings north of it can be set back. Before that happens it is possible that political and other circumstances will permit of a_ new outlet for ithe Yangtszepoo-Markham Road traffic. Meanwhile the many correspondents now writing to us, and who do not agree with Mr. Maguire's views of necessary improvements, are asked to call en Mr. Hughes at the offices of the China United Assurance Society, 31 Peking Road, and sign the petition for the protection of the Gardens.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.