The Archive · 1927

A Missionary's Views

"At the beginning of the meeting 'Mr. Burnett suggested that, in-tead of the usual questions, it might be better if there was a discussion. Accepting this sugzestion, the Rev, LI, T. Ford said he was' not a politician, but only a simple missionary who had lived ports, lo thousands China way y from the cee Chinese among his friends. His feeling while listening to the address was that he wished he had the same ability to express the real truth as Mr. Burnett had to express the partial truth. Until the Labour Party began its propaganda in China the British were the dest. ids the Chinese had, but the Labour Party propaganda had altered that, This was not because the British had done anything to injure the Chinese, but because of the manipulation of facts which' to do so easily. The result was that the Chinese had got distorted idea about the British just as Mr. Burnett had some distorted ideas jabour the conditions in China, He only wished people would go and live in China for five years before they started talking about it. Mr. Burnett had obtained his "ideas from people who ted lived in China perhaps a few weeks few months, He had lived 80 years in China, and had visited many of the treaty ports where Mr. Burnett said the Chinese were being ex-plaited, and he was quite sure the Chinese there did not wish to give up their jobs. Mr. Burnett was also wrong in what he said about. Chinese methods of fighting. There fore hundreds of defenceless mis-their stations because the ese troops had looted their home He held no brief for the militarists China, As a missionary he believed that the only way to bring Pro- eae was to preach the Gospel, not by discord, Mr. Ford was subjected to interruptions from certain. members of the audience, to whom his views were evidently not palatable, and as they coninued efter the chairman had asked that he be given a hearing, Mr. Ford resumed his seat.

Mr. Burnett thanked Mr. Ford for his observations, and said Mr. Ford's remarks about people writing on-Chnia after being there only a few months could not apply to Mr. Bertrand Russell, who was professor of philosophy at Peking. University for two years. He suggested that Mr, Ford might read Mr, Russell's book on "The Bible in China."

The Cause of Anti-Britixh Feeling Me, Burnett said he bad to admit he had not been to China, and if Mr, Ford's suggestion were adopted that only people who had been there should talk about it, the ques-ion would be left to a very small number of people. It was.a ques tion which concerned not only people who had been there. with China was cer-for all British people to discuss, Mr. Ford had asserted that there was no trouble in China until the Labour Party propaganda started.

Mr. Ford—I said anti-British feeling did not begin until then, and T only spoke for the part of China where T lived, Mr. Burnett seid the anti-British feeling could not be due to the Labour Party, which had conducted no propaganda in China, Tt could not be the Chinese Labour party, because it did not exist.

Mr. Ford—It is what is said in England by the Labour Party, and is telegraphed to China.

Mr. Burnett said the anti-Brit feeling arose in China itself, and modest factory conditions by the Peking Government were re. jected by the Shanghai authorities, fand if that was not sufficient to jereate an anti-British feelings he did Met know what was.

Mr. Ford said Mr, Burnett did not understand the Chinese, and had studied Chinese polities.in Ching for five years he would not talk: as, had been talking.

Mr. Cross, Patterdale, ushed Ford if he taught the Chivese the Sermon on the Mount, and, on receive ing an affirmative answer, went ask if that teaching corresponded with exploitation of Chinese children, for 12 to 16 hours a day at 2d. a days The Chinese not Exploited Mr. Ford said he did not ogre that they were being exploited, When he returned from, China to England last May he: was surprised at the colossal ignorance displayed by the British Press in almost. every newspaper, especially the "Daily, Herald." (A voice: "What.aboub the Daily Mail?'") From what be had seen of both papers, they could twist facts for their own special benefit. "The Times" was the only, paper whose articles appeared tu written by someone who. understood the Chinese. Most of the other. articles he had read seemed to be by people who had read about China, He was surprised to see Mr. Burnett, Iknew so much about China... He had got wip his ease very well, and the difficulty was to combat the truth of what he had said when it was nat all the truth, Mr, Burnett—You will agree'it, impossible to know all the truth, Mr. Pord said it was all bosh about the British trader exploiting the Chinese, who came hundreds of miles to got jobs at the const, The softest Jobs were at the Hongkong Shanghai Bank, where the suit of Chinese clerks were once persuaded: to come out on strike, Ford—They wanted in advance. (Laughter.) The trouble is you don't understand the Chinese mentality,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account