The Archive · 1928

The Negotiations with Nanking

Mar, 26.

Deep regret will be felt that Sir Miles Lampson has had to return to Peking before a settlement could be reached in the negotiations over the Communist outrages at Nanking a year ago. Everyone wishes to see that question disposed of and a settlement now would have been a happy termination to the Minister's tour, in all other respects so successful, The failure—it is to be hoped only temporary—is the more regrettable if what we read be true, in respect of the nature of the stumbling-Dlock, In statements that bear every mark of being inspired the "Sinwanpao" tells us that other points, such as re apology and punishment offenders, were practically set tied, but that the Nanking Government wished to include some reference to the firing by British and American men-of-war at the time of the outrage, and a statement of the British Government's, readiness to proceed to a gen-These two questions, we read, the British Government declined, to include in the agreement. Tt could never seriously have been ex-'Treaty revision do with these particular negotiations; it has been formally and publicly by Great Britain on more than one occasion, the only stipulation being that China herself should be in a condition to enter upon the requisite negotiations seriously, as a united State, That, unhappily, she is not yet; and it would therefore quite impossible for Great Britain to commit herself present to discussions with either of the rival Governments of China in the manner Nanking is said to desire It is easily understood that the Nanking Government, having accepted responsibility for the crime, seeks to save its face as much'as possible. We only wish that it could be brought, as a whole, to realize that the best and most effective manner of saving face, of: establishing its prestige beyond possibility of reproach, is to make plenary amends without trying to introduce other issues, If, as the "Sinwanpao" says, Nanking insisted on reference to the firing by foreign men-of-war, it must have known that it was asking what neither Great Britain nor any other Power concerned could allow. The only firing that occurred on that fatal day in Nanking a year ago was a protective barrage put round the group of foreigners who had taken refuge on Socony Hill from a murderous, unprovoked attack, If any of the as wore killed, their blood their own heads; they themselves have been disowned and their deeds repudiated by the Nanking Government, From that day to this no reprisal of any: kind has taken place, no undue pressure has been put upon the Nationalists to. make amends. Whatever other complaints China may have against Britain, the latter-has solemnly declared herself ready to redress to the beat of her ability; and she has king stands in a class by itself, a stain on China's good name which ought not to be left uncleansed. We are told on high authority that last summer, when the Nationalist Government, very properly, had admitted their liability to make amends, General Cheng Chien, commander of the army some of whose members had made the attack, volunteered his readiness to accept a public reprimand in order to facilitate a settlement. Considering that Liu Tsu-han, the Communist director of ' the army's political department, li now generally believed to have instigated the outrage, this re-Port, if correct, is most important, If General Chien can accept public rebuke in the matter, others need not be behind him, We are happy to believe that there is no lack of men in the Nanking Government who would fully share this view. Much credit is due to those who have been in touch with the British represent: tives throughout for unremitting efforts to bring matters to a successful conelusion. It is common knowledge that there are two parties within the Nationalist councils and it seems not improbable that an internal political conflict, which has nothing to do with friendship or antagonism towards Great Britain, has resulted for the moment in a deadlock. the circumstances, it is undoubtedly better that Sir Miles Lamp-should return to Peking; for if China has her self-respect to consider, so. has Great Britain, Meanwhile, the road to a happy conclusion of the negotiations is assuredly not closed. The "'Sin-wan pao" adopts an optimistic note, telling us that, although a settlement has been delayed, "both sides are anxious to avoid further misunderstandings and conclusion of the matter should be brought about as soon 8 possible." There can be no question that that is the desire on Great Britain's side. But it must not be overlooked that she regards herself, and justly so, as the aggrieved party. Innocent and unoffending British subjects have been wounded and murdered, their homes wrecked and pillaged; and Britain, with every means available for avenge ing them, has held her hand and waited patiently for redress, be-ise she wished to: prove her friendliness to the Chinese People and would not visit at large upon them the misdeeds of a few,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account