Mar. 27.
We published last week two telegrams, one from London and one from Boston, which, read together as they were placed in Juxtaposition, tell the romance and the tragedy of the submarine. The romance is that King Amanullah of Afghanistan made a voyage in Submarine L.22 from Portsmouth to Southampton "being submerged most of the way." The spectacular tour of the Afghan king, with his family and suite, isa hopeful augury of future peace on the oft troubled Northwest Frontier of India. For a hundred years Afghanistan has Been the meeting place for the conflicting policies of Britain and Russia in Asia, Many regretful incidents have occurred and the history of our intercourse with the fierce tribes inhabiting the territory north of the Hindu-hoosh that he, like Peter of Russi wants a window to the west? He envisages a time when the predatory tribes that menace his peace as much as the tranquillity of India will realize that peace is not only more profitable but, actually, more exciting than war. Afghanistan will settle down to civilized life to her own and to the world's benefit.
The tragedy is in the telegram from Boston which tells us-that the ill-fated U.S. Submarine S. 4, that was rammed and sunk on December 17, has been raised and the bodies of the unfortunate crew recovered. The six members of the crew who tapped their pathetic messages from the torpedo compartment had evidently died in their beds. The American nation was thrilled with hope that they might be rescued but the forces of nature were inexorable and, though brave men fought for their lives, the wind and the sea claimed their victims. Such disasters have more thin once befallen our own Navy and our sympathy is, therefore, the more spontaneous. There can surely be no more tragic ceremony than that witnessed when a wreath is dropped over the place where a submarine has been lost and it, ith its crew, resigned to their watery grave. The futility of the efforts at rescue when "all is done that can be done and all is done in vain," come home poignantly to the nation and we mourn with those who mourn for the brave that are no more. Invariably the question recurs, is it worth while? Is the price we pay for the security given us by this costly engine of war adequate compensation for the loss of 80 many lives? For every step forward, won in the conquest of the air or of the sea, has to be paid for in that'most precious of all coins, the lives of men. It is this haunting question that has led the Britis! Government, at Geneva, at Washington, and on several occasions since, to propose the abolition of the submarine as a weapon of war, We stand to lose as much as any nation by giving up this powerful but dangerous weapon, but hitherto our proposals have been refused consideration; chiefly by the smaller nations who see in the submarine a weapon of defence which they can afford to build while the costly "dreadnought is beyond their mean:
'The submarine evolved from the diving bell. Men learned that they could live for a time under water in that' apparatus and it seemed an easy step to dream of a contrivance that would make the diving bell, or something like it, move under water. In the sixteenth century a submarine boat was tried on the Thames by the order of James I. In 174 an inventor, named Day, lost hu experimental descent in Plymouth Sound. The Confederates constructed several submarines in the course of their war with the North but none was successful. France constructed the first useable submarines in 1881 and Germany pushed the craft to its utmost development during the late war. She entered on that great adventure with forty-six submarines, constructed 764 (on paper) and lost 210 in the course of the struggle, The submarine was a terrible weapon against unarmed merchant ves sels but disappointing when opposed to armoured ships, With the advance of science the submarine becomes progressively more powerful and has greater potentiality of destructiveness. It is, perhaps, only idealism to hope for its renunciation in war and, indeed, the question is involved in the larger one of the outlawry of war itself. This is being discussed, at the moment, by France and America and we would fain wish that it were within the realm of practical politics, As things are, its realization seems as remote as "that far-off divine event to which the whole creation moves". It involves no less than a radical change in human nature. If we wish to measure its improbability we have but to ask ourselves whether we, personally, would be willing to renounce the right of self-defence in every conceivable eventuality that could possibly befall us and then recollect that the outlawry of war means the same renunciation, not on the part of a few visionaries, but of masses of men, of like passions with ourselves, in many of whom the faculty of self-. straint is but imperfectly developed. We fear that for a long ime yet men must work and women must weep and such tragedies as that of the Sd must come in a world that is, as Tess said, like a bad apple fallen from a wind shaken tree,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.