The foreign traders of this} community in objecting to the arbitrary imposition of various! taxes not provided for by treaty, have at least two very substantial grounds for protest against such levies in Shanghai as_ the] extra tonnage dues, the thirty per cent. stamp tak on wines and spirits, Washington various high tariffs on luxuries which were to have been effeetive from September 1, and simile ay devices for raising the wind. In the first place they can justly claim that while there is no recognized government in China, government competent to discharge its obligations and k bargains, the only way to safeguard trade against ruinous levies is to adhere strictly to the lotter of the treaties until such 'a government does appear. They can grant that the conventional davitt of 6 per cent. is perhaps ridiculously fow and that China, if there were such a state, would be entitled to a sweeping revise ion of her whole tariff schedule and oven to tariff autonomy if the state were firmly established and could be trusted to deal fairly and wisely with—trad But in granting this. they insist, in the defence of what is left of commerce with this coun-that eight months and more ted by the Powers to conference in Peking Gat which every possibleveffort was made to put the temporary increases provided for at Washington in 1922 into effect, then to provide for interim tariff with much more Mberal increases, and to pave the way towards tarif€ autonomy' in 1919.
They must further dwell upon the fact that this conference was a failure for several reasons, the: major ones being that China could put forward no gove ment that could possibly execute old treaties or new agreements, that the Chinese delegation mel ed away and left the foreign delegates facing a few represen tatives of " government which the Powers could not recognize, and finally that the "Nationalis spokesmen in the South who were:
ming into control of inereasing areas and of many ports, threatened to wreck the Customs if the Washington surtaxes were put into effect by virtue of a bargain made in Peking. Since then no government which is party to the treaties governing the tariffs has recognized any administration in China as either the de jure or de facto government of China, s0 that it has deen at no time possible to resume discussion of tariff revision with a Chinese state. There has, however, been a determined effort, in the South particularly but in the North as well, by: unrecognized factions to" violate treaties and collect increasingly burdensome taxes by arbitrary one-sided action und without reference to-the inevitable damage In view of these efforts, the foreign merchants} ition to call upon their governments to hold the various local administrations to a strict observance of the treaty' tariff provisions and to permit of no evasion or violation of old bargains which, might be interpreted as a precedent leading to greater abuses.
This foreign community has also another legitimate ground for complaint which it can take own Municipal authorities, without further references ce the treaties than is necessary to show that they exist and - are!
I technically" in force, and, is the use by the Bank of China of its position: in _this Settlement as the Customs Bank for the extortion of illegal and arbitrary. surtaxes of one sort} and another in the interest of] the unrecognized "Nationalist" administration.
Here we have two appeal against arbitrary taxation in Shanghai by an_ unrecognized government which no international commission could refuse for an instant to recognize as valid so long as they were consistently presented and adhered to. Once the consistency of} either appeal is violated for the sake of expediency, however, clear issues are befogged and a way is left open for endless quibbling. And this, we are certain is precisely what has been effected by the judgment! for the plaintiff given by Judge p|Grain in the British Court on Saturday in the case brought by. Gande Price Ltd. against the Ocean Steamship Company for' delivery of the seventy-five cases. of beer held in the lotte godown. Instead of offering to pay the treaty tariff, namely five per cent. ad valorem, plus the legitimate wharfage and con: fancy dues, the plaintiffs are said in the judgment to ha offered in addition to pay two and a half per cent. surtax and two and a half per cent. luxury tax which, according to the text, ig "all that the Customs request."
The error lies in the fact that the total tariff said to have been offered, is just five per cent.
an the Customs is en-lof titled by treaty to request and presumably five cent, more than wag requested. The surtax-and luxury tax mentioned are, in the sight of all the treaty Powers, no more a valid charge upon commerce than the thirty per cent. stamp tax or the fifty-seven and a half luxury tax that was to have been collected in September. If the plaintiffs did actually: offer to pay these illegal charges they had no case whatever, for: they came into court admitting their willingness to pay one surtax which is in violation of. treaties while refusing to pay another on the sole ground that it is in violation of the same treaties, which is of course an absurdity. In the judgment it is further made to appear that the payment of the surtaxes mentioned was in accordance with the forms prescribed in the "Handbook of Customs Pr¢ cedure at Shanghai." This is! not specifically stated," but a casual reader would certainly et the impression that the Customs is a party to the collection of the surtaxes and lays down rules for their addition to the five per cent. tariff in the "Handbook." This impression is incorrect. The "Handbook" contains no rules for the collection of the surtaxes and the Customs ix no more a party to the collec-of the surtaxes which Gande Price Ltd. are id to have offered at the Bank of China than to the collection' df the thirty per cent, stamp tex which the Bank of China tried to impose on the consignment of beer, Tt be remembered that Sir Francis Aglen was dismissed from office for the very reason that he refused to instruct the'
Customs to collect or assist in ithe collection of these same surtaxes. It will also be remembered that Mr. Edwardes, the acting
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.