The Archive · 1922

A Question of Jurisdiction

Russian Litigants and the Mixed Court Can the Mixed Court take jurisdiction over a case in which parties are Russians, the plaintiffs being ''residents'' on board certain vessels belonging to the Russian Volunteer Fleet? This is a question that will be decided next week when Magistrate Tsang and N. Ivanow (Senior Consul's Assessor) will have before them she case which was postponed on Friday last in which the crews of the R. V.. F. str. I: an and Astrakan aye claiming 50,000 gold roubles as wages, alleged to be due to them since December 20, 1920.

Mr. L. Hartigan appeared for plaintiffs and Dr. O. Fischer acted for the defence.

Dr. Fischer, in opening, question: ed the jurisdiction of the Mixed Court in the case, and based his arguments on the mandate issued by the President_of the Chinese Republic in the Sth moon of the 9th year of the Republic that all Russian subjects shall be treated as non-treaty subjects. The memers of the crew, said Dr. Fisher, all lived on board the two steam: ers which were now lying in Chinese waters: therefore, submitted counsel, the case is one which should have been filed in the Shanghai (Chinese) District Court.

Mr. Hartigan submitted that the jurisdiction of the Court had already been decided upon the other day in the case Patstone and Patstone v. The Russian Volunteer Fleet. The ~Customs, said counsel, had already taken jurisdiction over the vessels which were tied up in harbour and could not get away.

"This is a Russian case," said counsel, ''and it should therefore he decided by the Russian Assessor, who is here to protect Russians."* Dr. Fischer pursued his objections and said that the case of Patstone and Patstone was an entirely, different one. "Plaintiffs in that case." he said, "were Americans and therefore the case was one to be brought before the Mixed Court. In regard to the Russian Assessor," Dr. Fisher submitted Court." In regard to the "Russian Assessor. That position was abolished together with the abolition of Russian'treaty rights in China "The present Assessor," he continued, "was only appointed by the Senior Consul, and could not-be called the Russian Assessor."

At this stage, the case was adjourned, the Court allowing Dr. Fisher three days in which to submit his brief on the question.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account