The Archive · 1928

The Monstrous Regiment

June 16, Some evenings ago at a dinner party, one of the male guests put it straight to the lady next him, to say why she and her sisters did not reintroduce polygamy. He having reached the age at which frivolity is held to be bad form, and she being young enough to be his daughter, it was impossible to misinterpret his intentions. He put the matter something like this: "When the flapper vote' (excuse me) becomes law, women will have all the political power in England besides other forms of power which yon already possess. One reads that there will be some two million [women voters more than men.

What is to become of all those women? What are you going to do about it?" The Indy addressed did not appear to think that she was called upon to do anything about it. But as nature has equipped her to appropriate as many men as she pleases and she has therefore no call to imagine herself under the necessity of sharing any man with two or three other women, her opinion was not, perhaps, impartial. Of other ladies who joined in the discus-ion, "some evidently could not imagine their husbands looking fat another woman; and all quite ly could not imagine themselves allowing their husbands do so. The men present seemed to be thinking deeply on the question, but they had hardly Jgot to the point of expressing themselves when the hostess was seen to be "collecting eyes" and, with the ladies trooping off into the drawing-room, what might: Ihave been a really useful discussion came to naught.

But the question is a serious lone. Was it not George Robey who used to sing "Why shouldn't every man have three wives?" Many a true word, we know, is fepoken in jest. After all, why shouldn't "he? And, what is more to the point, why do not the women. take the matter in hand and effect the necessary reform? Everything depends on' clear thinking, Polygamy fs confused with thoughts of nine-tailed Bashaws, odalisques, harem favourites and bowstrings. But this is merely the degradation of a once perfectly honourable practice, not necessarily against the practice, itself. When David was wandering Jabout the country in the guise of a flea and a partridge upon the mountains (his own deseription of himself), he was aecompanied by two wives, Ahinoam land Abigail. The latter know was an eminently practical young person and both of them must have been well used to roughing it; but all three seem to have been quite happy. Nowhere in the New Testament is polygamy expressly forbidden, except in the case of bishops, {In the year 1540, we read, Philip the Magnificent, Landgrave of Hesse, who, be it noted, was a lereat' reformer, proposed, with the consent of his wife, to marry Jo second one and did marry her. Martin Luther had theological objections, but, as a friend, he approved the step and the marriage occasioned no scandal of any kind. The law of England treats bigamy as a crime, But this is inconsistent with the three great prinefples on which our constitution rests, namely, self-government, _self-support, and self-defence. The first two lof these clearly allow us to take ithe Anabaptists' view, who as-Iserted the right of freedom in this matter. And with women in the majority in most western countries, it is high time that men began to look to their wen" [pons of self-defence, against the invasion of women into all bus: ness life; and to take them into their homes seems the simplest plan, In many respects life would certainly be simplified, ° When the Chinese first began to r Western novels with enjoy it was pointed out that some of four plots depended on perplexities to them incomprehensible. For example, the long issues that hang on whether David Copperfield ought not to have married Agnes rather than Dora. Any sensible Chinese would say, "Why not marry them both and be done with it?" This may suggest the fear that our literature would suffer by the reintroduction of polygamy. But some of the finest literature the world has ever seen was produced when it was a general custom; and the Song of Solomon proves that the "love interest" so far from being inconsistent" with polygamy is intensified by it, Expense may be held an objection, but this would be nothing compared with the amount of rebate which might justly be claimed from the infeome tax commissioners. It is not quite certain what the effect would be upon the divorce court's business, as we have no istles to show whether the fe's aversion for the: husband lor vice versd is the more prolific suse of marital disputes. But for reasons which will readily occur, one inclines to think that here too polygamy would justify itself by proving a cure for what is rapidly becoming one of the worst social evils of the day.

cannot, of course, be expected that the desired reform will approve itself immediately to everyone. A great deal of conservative prejudice has to be overcome. But as more and (Continued on page 486.)

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account