The Archive · 1933

SHADOWS LENGTHEN

Feb, 26.

As the situation develops in the North the responsibility for its aggravation becomes more clearly defined. The Japanese authorities at Tokyo are credited with repetition of the view that Fesistance to their occupation of Jehol must be debited with what. ever complications arise therefrom south of the Great Wall, General Tang Vu-lin is apparent: ly to be replaced by another Chinese leader who is more amenable to the requirements of Manchukuo, The feat of replacement will, in due course, demand military action to which Chinese opposition will be made at its own peril. Comment n this attitude is provided by the Report of the Committee of Nineteen which emphatically endorses the Lytton findings and is expected, in its turn, to be endorsed by the Assembly of the League. Mr. Winston Churchill hag advised the League to confine its attention to Europe. He shows a characteristically airy disregard of the foundations the Covenant to which, as a member of the British Government at the time, he was an important contributor. affects to see in Japanese agyression an unavoidable. measure of Aefence against Soviet. imperia-fiom, He fails to realise. that, recorded by the Lytton Report itself and reiterated by the Report of the Nineteen, the creation of the Commission of Inquiry' and its mission to Manchuria and the Far East directly arose from the specific request of Japan, where' representative on November 21, 1981, at the meet= ing. of the Council of the League in' Paxis, conveyed the anxiety of his Government for. the. obser-¥anee of the Council's Resolution September 30, 1991, "and "proposed that a Commission of Inquiry should be sent to" the spot." Moreover on December 10 1931 when the Council adopted the proposal and reaffirmed the resolution in" question,—the Japanese representative merely aualifed his Government's ac-Ceptance with the proviso that it Aid not preclude "the forces fron tak fon us might be rendere ossuary to. provide directly for Ehetprottclinn of the ven and Rietnt the actintes of bands perty. of Japanese. subjects

various parts of Manchuria." cements rampant in The suggestion that the League has unwarrantably interfered Jocks weak when, these simple facts are- recapitulated, The weakness is all the more marked if, certain passages in the relevant resolution of September 30 are recalled:

"Recognises the importance of the Japanese Government's, statement that it has no territorial designs Manchutias, notes the Japanese Fepresentative''s statement that his Government will continue zanidy as possible, the Grawal of its troops, which has Already "been begun, into the Fallway zone in proportion as the safety of the lives and property of Sapanese nationals. is effectively Assured and that it hopes to carry

Speedily as may" be.. notes, gut this Intention In" fil shat: the 'Chinese and' Japanese representatives have given garances that their Tospective Governments will take all nese Sary steps to prevent any exten-Bion of tho, scope of the incident or any aggravation of the situa-Hon."

Whatever view may be held regarding the responsibility for the dissipation of hopes herein outlined, it certainly can hardly be contended that the Lytton Commission or the League have been guilty of gratuitous interference with the course of events. Bren now, having "mars led the facts in most -painstaking fashion, the League is taking a line which even Mr. Churchill, whose own record is not lacking in provocative intrusion, cannot fairly interpret' as _quarrelsome or contumacious. Emphasis on these points is pertinent just now for the rapid gathering of the war-clouds over Jehol neces-creates acute anxiety is apt to find expression in mistaken accusations. Tokyo has not been averse from encouraging the generation of a smoke-Screen "of uninformed criticism of the League. Thence itis an easy step to reinforce the view that for untoward happenings in Jehol Chinese delinquency must take the blame. Tokyo, sta with thew convincing premise that Jehol art of Manchukuo—a premise solely on the inclusion of Jehol in the proclamation which announced the inauguration of the new state—suggests that Japanese military measures there on behalf of Manchukuo should not opposed. If they are opposed then the Japanese authorities disclaim responsibility for any extension of the zone of ope tions while vigorously deny any desire for such an addition to be made to their commitments. special surprise; successive Japanese pronouncements of the last seventeen months. It cannot, on that account, be allowed, to go unchallenged. The Report of the Committee of Nineteen makes that quite clear. China may oppose the forcible seizure of Jehol at her immediate peril materialization, but which is none the less plain to those who perceive the implications of world-opinion manifested in the League's findings. Coercion of Japan by the Powers or by the League there will not be, but the inexorable corrective of fore stirred up without certainty of control cannot be lightly dis= missed. In this moment—of strained economfe difficulty all who are concerned gin the preservation of pencef%l conditions in China must regard with grave apprehension a reckless invitation to the elements of discord to spread their malign influence in the North. If, as seems probable, the Chin authorities in Jehol consider it their duty to resist in spite of the ultimate hopelessness of the gesture, can anyone set a certain limit to the area of the resultant, hostilities? Once the word has gone to the Japanese General Stall for the seizure of Jehol, the course troop movements must depend entirely on the view taken by the General Staff of the military exigencies as the ise. In such a turmoil vision is bound to be blurred. The initiative rests with Japan; the possession of superior military strength goes with it. The stronger party Ean perhaps limit. its. commitments provided it remains strictly on the defensive but, once it resumes operations for extending its influence, the situation again is charged with dynamic possibilities beyond the power of anyone, in advance, to determine. Last year Japan could face such a problem with at least the excuse that she had no sure guide to the world's opinion. To-day that opinion is unmistakable. It gives no hint of, justification for the seizure proposed; the findings of the League's instruments of inquiry prescribe means for satisfying Japan's. legitimate aspirations in Manchuria without recourse to-arms. As the shadows lenge then over the North, this sense of caution should find freedom for expression. It is almost the only hope of averting a catastrophe, the outcome of which is surmised only. in terms of perplexity and dismay.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account